8 Comments

Summary:

EEStor, the energy storage developer, has no shortage of skeptics. That comes with the territory when making ambitious claims about turning energy storage on its head while revealing little evidence as to how. And while Canadian electric vehicle maker and EEStor backer Zenn has bet heavily […]

EEStor, the energy storage developer, has no shortage of skeptics. That comes with the territory when making ambitious claims about turning energy storage on its head while revealing little evidence as to how. And while Canadian electric vehicle maker and EEStor backer Zenn has bet heavily on the stealthy startup’s technology — which both say will enter commercial production this month — General Motors is watching EEStor from afar. In a new interview with GM-Volt, Tony Posawatz, vehicle line director for the Chevy Volt, says, “The guys involved” with EEStor “aren’t a fly by night operation.” But he also admits that some of the company’s claims, “knowing what I know, are way out there.”

EEStor’s pledge to build ceramic batteries at half the price, a fraction of the weight and 10 times the energy density of lead-acid batteries, however, is enough to make Posawatz “take note and follow it.” In the event that EEStor makes good on its claims, GM-Volt asked Posawatz if the startup’s devices could replace lithium-ion batteries in the upcoming Chevy Volt. “It would take a couple of years,” the exec replied, but it would be possible.

We wouldn’t bet on that possibility becoming practical, however, in the near future. Having logged a quarter of a million miles on the road in pre-production Volt models, built more than 300 prototype battery packs and completed tests for more than 50,000 lithium-ion battery cells, GM said last month that its Chevy Volt is on track to meet its remaining production milestones less than a year from launch.

GM still has room to improve on energy storage for the Volt — notably extending battery life and managing energy storage in hot climates and cutting costs. Progress in these areas will be significant in the competition to win over consumers to plug-in vehicles at mass scale. But the hurdles on GM’s to-do list appear relatively low compared to those on the risky, uncertain path ahead for Zenn as it seeks to transform itself from a neighborhood electric vehicle maker to a drivetrain supplier using as-yet unproven energy storage devices from EEStor.

Posawatz’s comments highlight the reality that it would take more than proving the skeptics wrong by meeting its performance and cost goals for EEStor’s devices to really transform transportation. After commercial unit No. 1 — which could still be delayed — there remains deals to be made, hundreds of prototypes to be built and millions of miles of testing to log.

Related research

Subscriber Content

Subscriber content comes from Gigaom Research, bridging the gap between breaking news and long-tail research. Visit any of our reports to learn more and subscribe.

By Josie Garthwaite

You're subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

Related stories

  1. EESTOR/Zenn story Update. A must read.

    http://gm-volt.com/forum/showthread.php?p=33960#post33960

    Share
  2. I used to have high hopes for EEStor. Now, though, after missing release date after release date, I’ve come to the conclusion that they’re either misleading everyone, or they simply don’t know what they’re doing. The dates move like the slipperiest of snakes; the latest was “end of 2009″, and I hate to tell ya, there’s not a lot of wiggle room left there. :(

    Share
  3. EEStor is out, Steorn is in:

    http://www.steorn.com/

    Share
  4. GM execs tend to never say bad things about competition in the public. They are very polite. In reality, I’m sure Tony thinks nothing of EESTOR and just said nice things that mean nothing.

    Share
  5. [...] Chevy Volt Exec on EEStor: Claims Are “Way Out There,” But Worth Watching EEStor, the energy storage developer, has no shortage of skeptics. That comes with the territory when making ambitious [...] [...]

    Share
  6. Richard P.Gagliardi Friday, December 18, 2009

    I think I have a way to produce over 2.5*10^18watts/yr of clean restorable utility power.

    Share
  7. Steorn is not for real… Nothing like trying to talk over our heads to try to convince us that they have a simple solution to perpetual motion that also creates energy even after taking into account “all of the drag from friction from the spinning top and the friction of the current through the wires”.
    Notice that when he reverses the polarity of the wires going into the motor, the motor spinns backwards… that’s not interesting at all. Take any motor from radio shack and flip the polarity of the battery.

    On that note: EEStor is deffinately a scam – there is no known material that can prevent electrons from transfering across it in the form of a thin film… slow them down yes, stop them.. no.

    Share
  8. [...] Zenn Motor has come to the end of its life as an electric car maker. The Toronto-based company’s announcement late Thursday that it has ceased production of its Zenn LSV model and laid off 15 employees who supported sales, marketing and production of the vehicle, marks the final shift to focus its efforts and financial resources entirely on a bet that ultracapacitor startup EEStor will make good on its ambitious performance claims. [...]

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post