23 Comments

Summary:

Forget multitouch: By far the most disruptive — and overlooked — feature of the Flash Player 10.1 beta that Adobe launched this week is the ability to transmit video via P2P multicast. In fact, Adobe built some enhanced P2P capabilities into both the new Flash Player […]

Forget multitouch: By far the most disruptive — and overlooked — feature of the Flash Player 10.1 beta that Adobe launched this week is the ability to transmit video via P2P multicast. In fact, Adobe built some enhanced P2P capabilities into both the new Flash Player and Air 2 beta that could be used to replicate BitTorrent functionality within Flash, build large-scale P2P groupware solutions that work right within the browser and stream video to millions of viewers without having to pay a fortune for bandwidth.

Adobe has been hinting at big plans for P2P ever since it bought a small P2P startup called amicima in early 2007. It made some of amicima’s technology available to developers about a year ago, but restricted it to small-scale use cases like P2P video conferencing or multiplayer games based on a few Flash players directly connected to each other via P2P. With Flash Player 10.1, Adobe appears ready to open the floodgates. CDNs and P2P video solutions providers would be well-advised to take notice.

Adobe’s P2P technology is based on its proprietary Real-Time Media Flow Protocol (RTMFP), which was previously restricted to one-to-one connections. That means your Flash Player 10 could directly exchange data with another client, but not relay the data. Transmitting video to 10 other clients meant opening 10 connections to other Flash Players, a method that doesn’t scale very well.

All of that changed with 10.1, which supports true P2P multicast, making it possible to retransmit a video stream from a single source to a large number of viewers. And not just a few hundred viewers, or even thousands. “When we think of large, we think of millions,” amicima co-founder and Adobe P2P Project Lead Matthew Kaufman said when he introduced the technology to developers at last month’s Adobe MAX event. In fact, he said, it should be capable of handing viewing audiences larger than that of the U.S. presidential inauguration, which has to date been the largest live-streaming event ever.

Kaufman’s MAX presentation, which is available as an archived video online, is fairly technical, but it contains a few very interesting tidbits. Adobe put a lot of work into making Flash P2P both scalable and reliable, which is why it combined a number of cutting-edge video delivery mechanisms. Publishers can, for example, distribute a video stream via IPv6 multicast and back it up with P2P multicast, or they can source a stream from a server and then opt to distribute it via P2P. Kaufman also claimed that the latency of Adobe’s P2P implementation is a lot lower than many of the existing P2P video solutions out there.

The whole experience should be pretty painless for the end user. “A permission dialog box will pop up for people using Flash Player 10.1 in the browser for P2Pmulticast,” I was told by Adobe’s Flash Media Server product manager, Kevin Towes.

But wait — Adobe’s got a few more P2P tricks up its sleeves. Developers will also be able to use Flash player 10.1 to build various other P2P applications right within the browser as well as within Air. One possible scenario mentioned includes object replication, more commonly known as file-sharing. “It’s a lot like BitTorrent”, explained Kaufman, adding that one could use this to “write a crazy file-sharing application” or to “replicate how Groove worked in Actionscript.” Adding to that, Air 2 now supports writing your own file servers and similar stuff through a dedicated API.

We’ll probably still have to wait a few months before we can get a true grasp on what all of this is going to mean for online video delivery, but there’s obviously a potential for huge disruptions. For starters, P2P video companies might have a hard time convincing publishers to opt for their solution, if only for the fact that end users won’t have to install any additional plug-ins to access Flash P2P video streams. At the same time, P2P adoption could skyrocket, as live-streaming sites and others start to leverage Flash Player 10.1 to cut down on bandwidth costs.

So what’s in it for Adobe? Well, RTMFP is true P2P, but you still need a so-called rendezvous server to connect users to the P2P swarm before they can access the video. Adobe already offers this functionality though a hosted service called Stratus, which is capable of serving hundreds of thousands of simultaneous users. In the future, you’ll just use your own Flash Media Server as a rendezvous server. In other words: Adobe’s use of P2P may cut out a whole bunch of middlemen, but it still places the company itself squarely in the center of the online video world.

  1. This is worth keeping a very closae eye on, if they can get flash working on the mobile devices this could really fly.

    Share
  2. What about searchability? How can users search for a certain video with this? Can they even search?

    For this to take over p2p, they need a way for users to search for videos they want to find. Without searchability, it is just a refrigerator without any food in it. People will at most look into it once and then never again. And many others will just hear that it has no food in it and not even look in once.

    Share
    1. John Curiousity Monday, November 23, 2009

      Scott the point of this is that it allows for a managed P2P/Multicast cloud thereby reducing the cost of content delivery. I think you are not understanding that here P2P means “Peer 2 Peer Technology” and not the generalized P2P in the media that typically refers to pirated material.

      Share
      1. And all the searching capability needs to be built on top of flash.. as part of the application built on top of Flash. Flash is a platform not the end application.

        Share
  3. Janko Roettgers Sunday, November 22, 2009

    Scott, BitTorrent the protocol doesn’t offer any search either. That hasn’t really stopped it from becoming very, very popular.

    Share
    1. But there are search engines that do search BitTorrent. Do any search this thing from Adobe?

      Share
      1. John Curiousity Monday, November 23, 2009

        You guys are a bit off the path with your comments. The point of the above news is that content owners, those in the enterprise etc. can leverage a managed P2P Multicast cloud to lower the cost of content distribution. The end goal is not to provide BitTorrent trackers that allow for file movement, etc.

        Share
      2. Do a search for YouTube videos and see what pops up. This will be no different Flash videos using peer-to-peer. Also if you want to harp on this issue, in Adobe’s Premiere CS4 has speech recognition capabilities which can create a text file for captions in the Flash video, with the timing of the caption synced up with the video. This will give greater search inside particular videos. Meanwhile, Adobe’s has demoed that they are working on this technology to work server side, although Google has already created their own solution without Adobe for YouTube.

        However, searchability is not a problem and is just a completely different issue. The big deal about all of this is that live events will be a fraction of the costs of what they cost now. This means we will likely see a LOT more live events online as they become easlier and cheaper to do.

        Although I’m curious about how the internet infrastructure would handle multiple large live internet events happening at the same time.

        Share
      3. I think what’s lost in this discussion is that we’re talking about the delivery mechanism. We’re talking about how live video is delivered to the end user. When you talk about search, I assume you mean searching some archived video after it has already been broadcast live. So you can still record the live feed (via FMS or maybe locally at the encoder, whatever). That video is still searchable to whatever extent videos are searchable today.

        Share
  4. Janko Roettgers Monday, November 23, 2009

    John, you’re right, Adobe is targeting content owners (or rather video platforms) with this, not file sharing users. But of course a Flash developer could use this to develop something that would allow file sharing. Whether or not that would take off remains to be seen. My point was that you don’t have to distribute search in order to make P2P work in a file sharing context.

    Share
    1. slave_of_code Monday, December 6, 2010

      already tested and it works easily for file sharing (at least with small userbase) if it’s the right technology for this … i really doubt! For me, the possibilites, like you told, are revolutionary for video/chat systems “outsourcing” the bandwidth to the user. Its just awesome, i only started with as3 & flex 2 days ago just because of this “new” (at least for me) development. And the good on that is that it is very easy to learn. you can implement voip, video sharing and chat system within 1 hour of work into your website. I just started to love Adobe!! OMG

      Share
  5. This is very interesting, great pick up, Janko!

    I wonder if an offshore site could use this to build a streaming site offering pirated video at a fraction of the costs of presently serving decent quality video. If so, expect the MPAA to start having heart attacks any moment now.

    Share
  6. [...] e trasmettano video a milioni di spettatori, senza dover pagare una fortuna in banda Internet, spiega [...]

    Share
  7. Hopefully it will help make a case for rightful use of P2P, enhance streaming speed and cut down on ISPs trying to control our packages.

    Share
  8. [...] event, for example – this often occurs right at the routers. With Flash player 10.1, Adobe is making it possible for content distributors to multicast content by having viewers transparently share the [...]

    Share
  9. [...] (51:25) Flash 10.1 adds a lot of cool stuff, including Bittorrent-like video distribution [...]

    Share
  10. [...] (51:25) Flash 10.1 adds a lot of cool stuff, including Bittorrent-like video distribution [...]

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post