7 Comments

Summary:

Although El Gato’s EyeTV app has been able to stream content over AT&T’s seemingly fragile 3G network since last month, it wasn’t until this past weekend that people were talking about it. That talk, at Gizmodo, was followed by swift and decisive action by Apple. EyeTV […]

eyetvapp_warningAlthough El Gato’s EyeTV app has been able to stream content over AT&T’s seemingly fragile 3G network since last month, it wasn’t until this past weekend that people were talking about it. That talk, at Gizmodo, was followed by swift and decisive action by Apple. EyeTV is no more at the App Store.

For those who don’t know, the EyeTV app accesses content from an EyeTV, the company’s television recording device, attached to a Mac, and sends it to an iPhone. As the pictured warning from the app clearly states, a Wi-Fi connection is required. However, tapping the warning text instead of the “OK” button enables streaming over a cellular connection.

Unfortunately, that’s a violation of AT&T’s terms of service in the U.S. and Apple’s policy everywhere else. Just last month, another video streaming app, SlingPlayer, was released in Europe, still shackled to Wi-Fi only. Sad, but those are the rules, which makes you wonder why El Gato broke them. According to Julio Ojeda-Zapata of Your Tech Blog, El Gato says “test code” was “accidentally left in the EyeTV app.” El Gato has already resubmitted a version of the EyeTV app without the offending code.

Personally, I applaud El Gato for its user-friendly sloppiness. The real error here is allowing telecommunication companies to regulate content on any network.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. “The real error here is allowing telecommunication companies to regulate content on any network.”

    It’s their network. If you don’t like it, switch.

    1. The whole point about “safe harbour” protection is that you don’t know what is being carried by your network. Either network operators are in the business of taking responsibility for every packet on their network (which they _really_ don’t want to do) or they aren’t.

      It grates when they try to have it both ways, and it grates even more when Apple lets them.

  2. Just use in the uk
    iphone.tvcatchup.com/
    Ive been using that since i got my iphone for tv

  3. The problem is all the carriers get together and block…leaving your only option to move to a new country. There is a glimmer of hope with the government backing net neutrality and 4G networks coming out in a year or so.

  4. Apple actually returned the App to all stores later that day. It is still currently available at 1.0.0 in the stores – Elgato spoke to this site http://www.totalapps.net/news/eyetv-pulled-apple/

  5. Sure it’s their network. It’s their marketing too, though. If they tell you have X GB of bandwidth per month, I expect to be able to use that bandwidth as freely as I want (or nearly).

  6. EyeTV Returns to the App Store, Minus 3G Streaming Tuesday, October 20, 2009

    [...] Written on October 20, 2009 by Darrell Etherington and No one has commented As we reported just yesterday, Apple didn’t take too kindly to El Gato’s “accidental” inclusion of a [...]

Comments have been disabled for this post