25 Comments

Summary:

The timing of news from Cupertino is eerie. They’re shouting from the rooftops that over two billion apps have been downloaded to the over 50 million iPhone and iPod Touch devices sold. Obviously, when we recorded our latest podcast a few days ago, we had no […]

windows-mobile-logoThe timing of news from Cupertino is eerie. They’re shouting from the rooftops that over two billion apps have been downloaded to the over 50 million iPhone and iPod Touch devices sold. Obviously, when we recorded our latest podcast a few days ago, we had no idea that Apple would hit these numbers today. But we focused our entire show on Windows Mobile — what was once a leader in the smartphone space. And I have to wonder: why isn’t Microsoft sharing the numbers of available applications for its platform?

See, that’s one of the common responses I get when I talk about Microsoft becoming a potential “also-ran” to Apple, Google and Research in Motion. Folks defend the platform passionately with quotes like “I can install any third party app on my Windows Mobile device and there are tens of thousands of them out there.” Or “Windows Mobile currently has every single other platform beat hands-down in terms of app library due to its long history.” Good points. Apple says there are now 85,000 applications in their store, but I really have no idea how that compares to the Windows Mobile space. Nor do any other consumers.

I know that I’ve used a fair share of third-party applications during my WinMo days. Some of them were outstanding and I’d load ‘em up on every WinMo handset I had. And I suspect that many of you have felt the same joy about certain programs in the past. So why then, isn’t Microsoft defending Windows Mobile in this regard? I’m sure it’s difficult to determine the exact number of applications available for Windows Mobile since there isn’t yet a centralized place to find them, but even an estimate would be handy, no?

  1. The easy answer is that they don’t force you to use their own app store (yet), so they don’t have the access to the numbers that Apple has as far as how many apps are available and how many copies have been sold.

    One thing that I think is fascinating is how Microsoft is becoming the more “open” of the two companies, at least in the mobile space. At this point, the fact that you can get your apps from anywhere and things like the widget feature in WM6.5 actually uses the W3C standard for mobile widgets are fairly contrary to what a lot of people would expect from Microsoft.

    Share
    1. Tim the “open” point is interesting. Do you think Microsoft will try to have it both ways and allow for apps to be installed from anywhere a year or so after they open their app store? If so, I’m wondering if they’ll get the full benefit of having an app store or it will just water down the notion of it.

      Share
    2. I don’t know. Every indication that I see is that they won’t allow “side-loading” of apps, at least without some hacking. On the other hand, would they really cut themselves off at the knees and prevent you from loading all of the applications that people have purchased over the years?

      My educated guess is that they will allow you to load apps without using the Windows Marketplace, but developers (at least the commercial ones) will see the benefits of getting their apps in Marketplace.

      I really don’t see the future of Windows Mobile to be as bleak as some would say it is.

      Share
  2. Thanks for stating my thoughts. I have an expired contract with VZW and want new “smartphone” with all the bells and whistles. BUT, I want to enjoy some of the iPhone apps and cannot really find that many for WinMo. I am waiting until after the WinMo launch next week to decide about a new phone.

    Share
  3. In our area, if you want a Smart phone,
    it’s either a Blackberry or a WinMobile phone.

    Windows mobile seems to have alot of freeware
    programs that you can find on different sites.
    I can get an app to do about anything for no charge.
    If you want/need a fancier more complex programs,
    then you have to pay of course.

    Does iPhone apps have a freeware base as well?

    Share
  4. i still find calling iphone a smartphone weird.

    or maybe i should start talking about my j2me enabled phone as a smartphone?

    Share
  5. I don’t see the point of playing this numbers game and don’t even understand why Apple does. Apple’s AppStore has a reputation for iFart-style apps and that impression is only reinforced by the release of these types of figures. Do you really believe that every iPhone/iPod Touch user has downloaded 40 high quality apps? Of course not. How many of these apps are so good that the user couldn’t live without them or would consider downloading them again? I’d wager only a few.

    As everyone knows, quality is more important than quantity. I’m not suggesting that all WinMo apps are great (god knows I’ve seen my share of crap WinMo apps) but there’s no point boasting that you’ve got large numbers of poor quality apps.

    Share
  6. Microsoft did tout their apps when the iPhone was first released in a press release where they claimed 18,000 apps. But that seems pretty small now doesn’t it?

    Share
    1. I’d think they have more than that. But then again, it appears that developers are following the handset sales and devoting resources to other platforms. Hmm…

      Share
    2. Not according to their OWN press release! I will remind you even the 18K number is for ALL apps, not all of them run on every Windows Mobile device.

      Share
    3. Here you go:

      According to the WinMo team back in July 2008 they provided some facts and figures:

      * Windows Mobile sold more than 18 million licenses in fiscal year 2008, seeing triple digit gains in France, Latin America, Central and Eastern Europe, Japan and India.
      * Consumers today can enjoy a number of Windows Mobile 6.1 phones, including the HTC Diamond, Touch Pro, and Samsung Omnia, and anticipation is rising for upcoming devices such as the Sony (NYSE: SNE) Xperia X1.
      * We continued strengthening our position in the enterprise evident by 363 lighthouse wins (500 devices or more) which equaled 1.4 million total licenses; 91 were competitive (meaning a RIM (NSDQ: RIMM) BES server was decommissioned).
      * We have more than 18,000 Windows Mobile applications, recently adding applications from Bloomberg, Reuters, and SAP (NYSE: SAP), giving people the choice and flexibility they demand.
      * We are continuing to leverage acquisitions including Danger, MobiComp, Musiwave, and aQuantive to deliver the best mobile experience in the market

      I guess they have little to say now!

      Share
    4. Thanks for the additional info, Stephen. And a great point (also made by others) that some of the apps only run on certain versions of Windows Mobile. I find that strangely similar to the legacy challenges Microsoft has faces on the desktop as well, no?

      Share
    5. By the way, I’m now thinking that the 18,000 apps can’t be right. I found a 2005 Microsoft press release about WinMo 5.0 and it uses the same figure! Ugh…

      http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/press/2005/may05/05-10windowsMobile5PR.mspx

      Share
    6. And a little more digging — see what you started Stephen! ;) — shows that in February of this year, Microsoft said they had 20,000 apps. This was in their press release announcing their own app store. https://www.microsoft.com/presspass/press/2009/feb09/02-16MWCPR.mspx

      Not a solid growth rate over the past several years, but as some have rightly pointed out, quality is more important than quantity.

      Share
    7. Wow, Kevin. I guess we can see why Microsoft does not want to tout these numbers since they had a ten year head start! Apple adds 2,000 apps in less than a week.

      Windows Mobile is stalled as it seems. There is talk of separating WinMo 7 and 6.5 among vendors and using the failed Zune strategy – Project Pink to have a new Microsoft phone. I don’t think this will stop Apple and RIM from continuing to beat them.

      I know the argument is among some is that the iPhone has useless apps. I disagree as there are over 11 turn-by-turn GPS apps alone. There are loads of very useful apps for the iPhone, really.

      Share
  7. > when I talk about Microsoft becoming a potential “also-ran”

    Potential? It very much is that. Quite frankly, I have been using mobile devices since the original Pilot and currently own an iPhone 3G, a Google ION and a Palm Pre, but I couldn’t even *name* a single current Windows Mobile phone or handheld by name anymore. When was the last time you saw one advertised on TV.. or in the newspaper?

    Now, we all know that today’s market leader can be tomorrow’s forgotten platform (say, Palm OS), and the iPhone could certainly be eclipsed by something else at some point, which could even come from Microsoft. But today they are dead and forgotten, as far as I am concerned. I think they really should have used the launch of Windows 7 to also restart their mobile initiative — tie things together.

    Share
  8. The other problem Microsoft faces in counting toes is how many of the apps are working on WinMo 6.5. Their own MSReader was an excellent example of this issue. It was MIA on 6.0/6.1 (and oft rumored to have been KIA’d) and I haven’t checked to see if it makes an appearance on 6.5 yet.

    The WinMo crowd likes to taunt over the app store’s restrictions but I’d point out that those restrictions come with a pay check. Just look at the number of freeware WinMo apps and ask “How many of those free apps would like to be able to collect $.99 each?” But until Apple came along there was much wailing and wringing of hands over how to collect micro payments for such developers: Apple made it work. Microsoft has already ceded the sub $2.99 market before selling even one app.

    Share
  9. The problem with saying how many winmo apps there are, that now there is the App Store, is how would anyone access them? 18,000 or 100,000 – unless there is an easy way to get to the apps it really doesn’t matter.

    Share
  10. GoodThings2Life Monday, September 28, 2009

    I have an HTC Touch Pro 2. It comes with a lot of stuff that I intentionally wrote a script to purge and tweak and improve. It screams now.

    I install exactly 10 things on it:

    1. Contact Changer (changes contacts sorting for all contacts).
    2. Facebook Mobile
    3. Kai ABC Editor — WordComplete Dictionary Editor
    4. Kai AutoCorrect.NET — Word Correct Dictionary Editor
    5. Microsoft Bing Search
    6. Microsoft .NET Compact Framework
    7. PHM Registry Editor
    8. S2U2 — Slide to Unlock
    9. SPB Mobile Shell 3.0
    10. Total Commander (File Explorer replacement)

    Most of those I only use occasionally. The ones I use daily are:

    1. Outlook (built-in for SMS/MMS/Email)
    2. Mobile Shell (Today / TouchFLO replacement)
    3. Facebook Mobile
    4. Microsoft Bing (not daily, but whenever I need gas and want it cheap)
    5. Slide-to-Unlock
    6. Internet Explorer (to Hell with Opera!)

    My point is… yeah, OK, sure, there’s lots of apps out there, but I don’t want or need thousands of apps, and I could care less how many are out there and even less still about how many are downloaded.

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post