9 Comments

Summary:

Google today is launching Google Sidewiki, which despite its name is actually a universal commenting system. The new service will be available via Google Toolbar. As the company said in an email explaining the feature: Sidewiki enables users who have installed Google Toolbar to contribute information […]

sidewiki-m.pngGoogle today is launching Google Sidewiki, which despite its name is actually a universal commenting system. The new service will be available via Google Toolbar. As the company said in an email explaining the feature:

Sidewiki enables users who have installed Google Toolbar to contribute information alongside any page on the web, inside of a simple sidebar UI. This information, which can include text entries, links, and embedded videos, will be ranked by quality and community ratings. For instance, on a site about a specific beach town, a user could add a relevant YouTube video showing local attractions. Once users opt in to the feature, they’ll be able to view annotations contributed by other users within a browser sidebar, and can choose to hide the sidebar at any time. Google Sidewiki also won’t change the appearance of any webpage – all Sidewiki entries will be displayed only in the sidebar.

Google group product manager, Caesar Sengupta, tells paidContent that the company is looking to “help foster and create communities around different web pages” especially on sites that lack community features. Which on the surface doesn’t mean much. After all, it is yet another Google feature, whose success is as debatable as the mental nourishment provided by late-night talk shows. Furthermore, many startups have tried to develop such services before and failed because consumers haven’t really cared for them.

But if you think about it, this is part of a larger trend. When it comes to information on the web, we all are facing a problem of plenty. As I have noted in the past, our current paradigm of looking for information via Google will be challenged. So the best way forward is to get some human intervention, something that was championed by Yahoo a few years ago. Some are doing it by mining Twitter. Google wants to do it via Sidewiki.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. Hope they build this into Chrome, since it doesn’t have a toolbar.

    1. That would make perfect sense. I think it would be pretty cool to have this built into the browser/OS because then it is perfectly useful.

  2. interesting concept — not sure how this will plugin to existing sites with comments… will they give you an api to call to and suck the comments back out? or will they give you something to put on the page to push the comments to the sidebar

  3. so Digg redux? or StumbleUpon without the stumbling? Surprisingly little innovation considering the source…

  4. I tried to download it, but it gave me an .exe file, so I guess Mac is not included yet?

  5. Are you guys nuts to call this interesting concept? This concept has been tried by a lot of guys earlier and has not been successful. So, what is Google doing new in this area?
    The fact remains that you need Google Toolbar to comment and see the annotations (correct me if I am wrong). I for one do not have GToolbar installed and am not going to install one, just for this feature.

    1. You mean like if you were using Googles chrome browser which doesn’t have a google toolbar? :)

  6. I think others have failed for the same reason this project may. To much effort is required by people who either wont know this feature exist or wont understand how to use it.

    Lots of average users will just look for this type of feedback on the site itself or other forums geared toward feedback and reviews of a site.

  7. Google grabbed idea http://yousticker.com
    YouSticker.com – it’s social utility tool for commenting everything everywhere on the web
    Without toolbar and support all browsers!
    Have support signup from twitter, google, openid account
    Crosspost in your twitter
    Have followers, following, groups, privacy

Comments have been disabled for this post