39 Comments

Summary:

A few weeks ago my dad had some pretty hefty surgery. All told, the surgery itself was seven hours long, and by the time I left the hospital it was almost a 14-hour day. He was in the hospital for almost a week and by the […]

iPhone3GS-2

A few weeks ago my dad had some pretty hefty surgery. All told, the surgery itself was seven hours long, and by the time I left the hospital it was almost a 14-hour day. He was in the hospital for almost a week and by the end of his stay, one thing had become very clear: my iPhone had become the command center for my life and had squashed any thoughts I’d ever had of getting a netbook.

I’m not saying I don’t think there is a market for a device that’s larger than an iPhone but smaller than a MacBook — heck a few years ago when I was covering E3 for the gaming industry, I’d have loved a small device I could sit in a corner of the show floor and could bang out copy on. While researching this article, I took a gander at the Dell Mini 10v (the spiritual successor to the Dell Mini 9, only with a 120GB drive and larger keyboard with standard key placement) and had a few minutes of drooling and fantasizing about a small laptop to write on during lunch, or a “throw it in my bag and not worry if it gets stolen” laptop before closing the web page and muttering, “Really, Crumpy, what the heck are you going to do with that? This could be another $300 device that sits in a corner.”

All Things Are Not Equal

It’s not a fair comparison to plop an iPhone down next to a hacked Dell Mini running OS X and proclaim them the same. However, while a netbook is a list of pros and cons when compared to a full-sized laptop, the iPhone is as well when measured against a netbook. For, me, though, the trade-offs are worth it.

I have a Whitebook as my primary computer. When Dad was in for surgery I had planned on working remotely on Elizabeth (all my computers are named from characters in Young Frankenstein) from the waiting room. With the amount of SMS messages, Twitter updates and e-mails I was sending out to concerned people, I ended up just moving files I was reviewing over to the iPhone and just worked off that. Since the iPhone had become Central Command that day, I could cut and paste updates very easily to the different mediums. It also helped that the work I had brought with me was a PowerPoint file I was reviewing and I could flip through that just as easily on the iPhone.

I’ve also found that, while I’m comfortable using my laptop on a desk, or propped up on a lap desk in bed, using it on my actual lap isn’t very comfortable. By contrast, as odd as it may seem, I was very comfortable working on the iPhone in the uncomfortable chairs in the waiting room. I certainly wouldn’t want to work eight hours on it, or do a heavy document revision, but, for flipping through a deck while SMSing, Twittering, and emailing, it was fine.

Being Productive

“This is a one time deal,” I thought to myself on the way home. “There’s no way I’m going to view the iPhone as anything resembling a laptop/netbook substitute.” Over the weekend, while spending lot of time watching Dad sleep, I’d crack open Elizabeth and try and work on articles. A combination of the glare from his window, more uncomfortable chairs, and the bustling of the nursing staff made the laptop difficult to use. I downloaded QuickOffice to try out, and before I knew it, most of my article on Macs in the Enterprise was written. I was amazed how productive I was for the task at hand — roughing out a blog post.

Really, though, I shouldn’t have been. Since the day I got the device, the iPhone has become more central to my life each and every day. While it doesn’t have a decent-sized keyboard, a large screen, or the ability to do complicated tasks, the iPhone does have two things going for it no netbook has: an always-on Internet connection at no extra fee other than my standard AT&T cell/data package; and the ability to fit easily in my pants pocket.

Comfort and Convenience

For me there are the two sweet spots: the always-on Internet and small size. I’m willing to accept the limitations of the platform. While most of my posts for TheAppleBlog and my personal site pass through the iPhone in some fashion, the WordPress web interface on the iPhone isn’t responsive enough to do the final edits and submit it — especially if there are graphics involved. For just creating content, I’ve had great success. More than a few paragraphs of this article were written on QuickOffice waiting for elevators and cafeterias to open. If I needed to finalize more articles remotely, that might tip the scales towards a netbook.

Until recently, I’ve always thrown my MacBook in the bag with me as I head to work. Unfortunately, using my personal Mac as my primary computer stopped being cute and was generating some serious issues for Corporate so I’ve had to stop using it. As more and more of my data and life exists in the cloud, combined with the ever-present connection the iPhone has to the Internet, I’ve started thinking twice about undocking Elizabeth and bringing her with me. I use Evernote on all my computers so I can tag and have access to all my notes regardless of what computer I’m on. I use Culture Code’s Things on the iPhone and OS X to manage my to-do lists. I use Google Sync to keep my calendars synced through the cloud between iCal and the iPhone, and use the web interface at work to quickly add entries. Since QuickOffice can read from an iDisk, I’ve started thinking of getting a MobileMe account just so I can work off the same version of a document from any computer.

Portability Isn’t a Big Issue for Me

I don’t travel enough to enjoy the benefits of the ultra-small size of a netbook. As I said earlier, if I were still covering gaming conventions where carrying around the a full-sized laptop all day would be grueling without a sherpa to lug the thing, or flying enough to want to work on the tray table, I’d be ordering a Dell Mini 10v and Hackintoshing it in no time.

Granted, It’s Not Perfect

That’s not to say everything has been lollipops and rainbows. The iPhone is a closed device with no native file management. The advantage to QuickOffice is I can grab files off my iDisk (iDisk or Dropbox syncing across multiple computers is the one remaining temptation I have for a netbook). Getting files onto the device is often a multiple-step process, and I might need to think ahead and identify key files I’d need access to without the cloud. Also, the screen really is too small to have any sort of reference material up — I play D&D every Friday with my friends, and it’d be nice to have a small device I can read reference materials from.

These quibbles are minor, though. With my iPhone I can write, surf the Internet, e-mail, watch movies, manage my life, and play games from a device that fits comfortably in the front pocket of my pants. Major, long-form work is done on Elizabeth. Anything netbook-sized to me feels like one of the beds Goldilocks rejected.

  1. @Mark “the WordPress web interface on the iPhone isn’t responsive enough to do the final edits and submit it ” have you looked into the free wordpress iPhone app. I use it frequently and love it.

    Share
    1. Yeah, I have. It has serious issues with the Apple Blog interface. But,I can’t do any formatting with it, so it’s good for quick posts.

      Share
  2. This is one of the best articles I’ve read about the iPhone. You have certainly captured what I think most iPhone users feel about their device. My husband, myself, my daughter, son-in-law, son and daughter-in-law could not live without our iPhones. I have used mine on travels from the top of Machu Picchu and from South African safari. I used to take a laptop, but fine the iPhone is more convenient and definitely more fun to use. I was just saying to my husband that the apps are far and away taking over the need to even browse the network … you can practically do everything via an app.

    Share
  3. http://blackrimglasses.com/archives/2009/07/11/my-netbook-vs-iphone-3gs/

    I posted something like this, but actually wrote it on my iphone ;)

    Share
  4. saschakronberg Tuesday, July 21, 2009

    spot on article! I am thinking the same. As much as I would love a touchbook or netbook from Apple, I am still thinking of how to make use of it. I have an iMac at work, as well as a MacBokk (which I hardly use).
    When I am travelling, most of the time, I do all work from the iPhone.

    Very well written, Mark!

    Share
  5. Speaking of the D&D, i’ve tried using one of the free file transfer/view apps to transfer the PDF versions of books that I own onto my ipod touch in hopes of not having to bring my laptop to game night. The smaller books opened, but the larger books seemed to just hang the system.

    Share
  6. Great article Mark! What would you consider to be the essential apps for making your iPhone a “netbook replacement”?

    Share
    1. QuickOffice
      Beejive
      Things
      Evernote
      Wordpress App
      dropbox as a web app

      Share
  7. A very good article. Thank you for not saying that an iPhone can replace a netbook. I have heard that countless times which quite frankly is ridiculous as they have many similarities with even more differences. You made it clear that there were limitations with both but you prefer the iPhone for obvious reasons. Nice article.

    Share
  8. Sensible take on this topic. I find my Macbook getting left behind more and more thanks to the iPhone.

    I still think there’s a market for an in-between device – in tablet form. With an optional wireless keyboard. No keyboard at the gate, on the plane, on the sofa. Keyboard when you need to crank out some text in your room, at your desk, whatever.

    Share
  9. Thank you for mentioning Quickoffice. We’ve put a lot of effort into the application and it is rewarding to see folks like yourself making good use of it.

    Share
    1. While I have you, any plans to add dropbox support?

      Share
    2. Dropbox are coming out with their own iPhone app shortly.

      It would still be nice to see OpenOffice support. I don’t fully trust using iDisk.

      Share
    3. Yeah, but I’m assuming that app is read only.

      Share
  10. yes, I just used my netbook budget to buy an iPhone 3GS!

    Share
  11. Michael Cheung Tuesday, July 21, 2009

    Good article. I used a NetBook (Acer Aspire One) fr a week and for the most part was a nightmare to work with. The keyboard was tiny, the trackpad useless, and performance was dire. Only when I plugged in a USB mouse was it slightly better. About the only thing I found it useful for was playing those Facebook games!!! And seeing some websites that were 100% Flash only. Flash compatibility is the only major positive advantage for the netbook in my brief experience. And even then I’m not sure it’s a good thing, because I can see my new iMac CPU spike up when flash extensions are enabled in Firefox 3.0. I would rather save the battery power on the iPhone.

    Share
  12. Once I got my iPhone 18 months ago, I sold my MacBook, and bought an iMac. The iPhone does everything I need a mobile device to do.

    Share
  13. Is the Iphone really that effective? I have been in the market for a phone that is like that for a while now. Right now, I’m using the Touch Pro from Sprint. It’s great, but far from a working phone, or far from what you all are saying you can do from your iPhones. I couldn’t imagine browsing the internet on this screen (although I could), because it’s just too small. Can you get the Skyfire browser on the iPhone?

    Share
    1. No. But Safari isn’t *all* that bad, and a lot of sites have mobile versions that are easy on the eyes.

      I wouldn’t want to work a full day on it, or write in anything larger than small chunks.

      Share
  14. Nice article. I concur on the always-connected and small-size features both being important. An emerging third for me is the current-location feature of the 3G / 3GS. This results in pure magic when finding nearby services or directions to somewhere else.

    More and more I look at laptops as being “blog-scale” and the iPhone as “tweet-scale”. The social web currently seems to be dictating more of the latter which bodes well for iPhone sales.

    Share
  15. Mark, InstaPaper has been useful for me with regards to view-ability. Integrating InstaPaper features with Mobile Safari + MobileMe backend could be a win for everyone don’t you think?

    Share
  16. [...] Written on July 28, 2009 by Mark Crump and No one has commented As I mentioned in the My Netbook: The iPhone article, my iPhone is central to my life. But one area that’s been a challenge is getting [...]

    Share
  17. Thanks for the article. Chalk up another reason for my getting a 3-gen iPod touch come September. The only negative is that Apple keeps blocking good iPod touch applications from the App Store just because AT&T doesn’t want them on iPhones. Like a number of others, I want a touch partly as a WiFi phone to save on T-Mobile bills and to manage Google Voice. AT&T shouldn’t have any say in that.

    My netbook experience fits with what you said. I thought I needed one, but by good fortune managed to pick up very cheaply a late 1990s HP Jornada mini-notebook that included a stripped down version of Word. Except for no WiFi, it was very much like a netbook. Despite my expectations, I found I had no use for it. If I needed to a laptop, my MacBook wasn’t that much harder to carry and was much more versatile. The iPhone/touch is another story. It is small enough to carry and use almost anywhere.

    There’s a further plus you didn’t mention. I have a couple of part-time jobs that have free moments when I’m just standing or sitting. There’s no way an employer would let me pop open a laptop. But checking the messages on a cell phone is so acceptable on the job today, that doing something that looks like checking message is fine. That makes it great for taking down story ideas as they come to me.

    Apple’s greatest failing with the iPod touch is the lack of models. As slim as it is, few would complain about an extended version with a larger battery. And those whose on-the-go lifestyles include the great outdoors would love a sport model much like the ruggedized and waterproof GPSs.

    –Michael W. Perry, author of Untangling Tolkien.

    Share
  18. antoinelamarre Thursday, July 30, 2009

    The Iphone’s lack of multi-tasking makes me think otherwise. Seriously, I prefer jailbreaking it to tether on a netbook or laptop

    Quickoffice is a great app btw.
    I hope they rethink the wordpress app because you can’t do much with it.

    Share
  19. No multi-tasking is a minor issue for sure, but I think a laptop and iPhone are two different animals. The laptop is ideal for blogging and documents; the iPhone is ideal for Twitter and mobile communication. Being able to tether the two would be nice.

    Share
  20. Just want to chime in. I appreciate your use of the iPhone and it’s good to read how functional it can be. I got the iPhone for the sole purpose of having a useful media/smartphone on me all the time that I can use for cheap calling (by cheap, I mean I use Skype-out and cancelled my rip-off of a land line at $30/month; Skype is $30 for a year!!!). The fact that I can jailbreak the iPhone and use backgrounder lets me have Skype open while I quickly glance at my email (still while yapping to family and friends, check twitter, or do multiple other things).

    Also, given that there are programs as Jaduu for remote desktop management, I can quickly update my blog via the iPhone without being on location to do the update.

    On the other hand, being in research, my Dell mini 9 (running OSX) cannot be replaced by my iPhone. They are simply 2 very very different tools for very different jobs. I cannot use TexShop/LaTeX on the iPhone to crank out an article, I cannot analyze my stats using R or matlab on the iPhone (all of these are done on the hackint0sh). I cannot grade papers and keep an Excel sheet running easily. Basically, I cannot do a lot of things comfortably on the iPhone that I can do on a 2lb netbook.

    Moral of the story, both smartphones and netbooks have their place in a consumer’s life. They both have their uses. They definitely do in my life at least.

    PS If I weren’t able to jailbreak the iPhone, I most likely would not have bothered with it. However, given the possibility of pwning it (if I may) and actually using it the way I choose to made my decision very easy.

    Tablet, I’m not so sure about. I’ve posted on another entry about my thoughts on the iTablet. Just imagine typing on something like that. How would you hold it? Would you bend over it while it’s on the table, just so that you can see the screen without distortion? I guess I won’t know until I try, but I can say with 100% certainty that it would not replace either my iPhone or my netbook.

    Cheers

    Share
  21. [...] mentioned before my iPhone is the command center for my life, and in that article I mention there’s no real end-to-end solution for me to blog on the [...]

    Share
  22. Hey very nice blog!! Man .. Beautiful .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your blog and take the feeds also…

    Share
  23. [...] been happy to use an iPad instead of my MacBook. My dad was in the hospital for a week and I found my iPhone was a better use for me than the laptop. In October, he and I took a road trip for a week. I hauled the MacBook with me, but in reality I [...]

    Share
  24. [...] been happy to use an iPad instead of my MacBook. My dad was in the hospital for a week and I found my iPhone was a better use for me than the laptop. In October, he and I took a road trip for a week. I hauled the MacBook with me, but in reality I [...]

    Share
  25. [...] been happy to use an iPad instead of my MacBook. My dad was in the hospital for a week and I found my iPhone was a better use for me than the laptop. In October, he and I took a road trip for a week. I hauled the MacBook with me, but in reality I [...]

    Share
  26. [...] written about my love affair with Quickoffice before, but there’s always been one issues I’ve had with it: the only cloud storage service it [...]

    Share
  27. [...] written about my love affair with Quickoffice before, but there’s always been one issues I’ve had with it: the only cloud storage service it [...]

    Share
  28. [...] written about my love affair with Quickoffice before, but there’s always been one issues I’ve had with it: the only cloud storage service it [...]

    Share
  29. Four Golden Rules of Stock Market Investing
    If you thought that investing in the stock market is very difficult then you need to rethink as it is not too complex as you think. It does require some home work before investing in the stock market but it gives you really good and fruitful results when you invest in the right stocks. You should learn the four golden rules of stock market investing that are very important to understand the stock market. Well you should keep in mind that you should never let your cash invested in the wrong stocks. After all it is your hard earned money and you should never let go your money into the wrong hands. So let us have a look at the golden rules.

    1) Make a good research

    Prior to making your money invested in the stock market, you should keep in mind that you make a good research on the stocks of a particular company. Even if you wish to go for online trading you need to research on the website so that you are not fooled by the different websites. You should know that there are many fraudulent websites that tends to fool the visitors to their websites. They make some fraud techniques like taking into account all the details of the bank or the credit card numbers. You would find that you have been robbed off your money that makes you go penniless. This should be very carefully handled when you go for buying or selling your stocks online. You should also try to understand the different useful concepts like NSE, NASDAQ, BSE…etc that are very important to understand the working of the market.

    2) Gain good confidence

    It is very important that you develop some good confidence so that you can become successful in making good income out of your investment. There are some people who lose all their hopes after losing quite a lot of money in the market. So stock market is not for them. You should try to face the reality and make a good interpretation of the market so that you can get good money from the money that you have invested in the share market. You should also try to get the best advice from an experienced person who would be able to guide you in order to get the maximum returns from your investment. You should never go for investing any money that you are not quite sure about its results. So you need to stop worrying and make the best effort in order to get good financial returns. When you gain good confidence you would be able to lay the foundations of your future financial returns.

    3) Look for the right broker

    If you are not really sure where to invest and when to invest then you need to find the right broker for you who would be able to guide you in order to get the right track. The broker would be able to make you the correct choice where you can be benefited from the market from the hard earned money that you have invested. There are also some brokers that charges high commissions and so you need to discuss these things with the broker prior to appointing the one for you. When you get the right broker you would not have to worry at all about losing your money in the stock market.

    4) Stay yourself updated

    You need to stay yourself updated on the latest scenario of the stock market. You can go for watching business and stock news and also read books on stock market. This would help you to stay updated and also help you to understand much about the stock market. You should remain quite abreast of the latest happenings in the stock market.

    Well these are the four golden rules of stock market investing. But you need to understand that there are other rules too that go hand in hand while investing in the stock market. Remember that it all depends on your knowledge of the stock market and also your research on how you can go for investing in the right and the best stocks.

    Share
  30. [...] been a little over a month since I’ve introduced the iPad to my digital workflow. In a post last year, I wrote, “I’m not saying I don’t think there is a market for a device that’s larger [...]

    Share
  31. [...] been a little over a month since I’ve introduced the iPad to my digital workflow. In a post last year, I wrote, “I’m not saying I don’t think there is a market for a device that’s larger than [...]

    Share
  32. [...] been a little over a month since I’ve introduced the iPad to my digital workflow. In a post last year, I wrote, “I’m not saying I don’t think there is a market for a device that’s larger than [...]

    Share
  33. [...] been a little over a month since I’ve introduced the iPad to my digital workflow. In a post last year, I wrote, “I’m not saying I don’t think there is a market for a device that’s larger [...]

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post