17 Comments

Summary:

It’s no secret that the iPhone was late to the video recording party. But Apple finally has added video recording features to its popular gadget, with the new iPhone 3G S. I spent a weekend with my iPhone 3G S, capturing several video clips to see […]

It’s no secret that the iPhone was late to the video recording party. But Apple finally has added video recording features to its popular gadget, with the new iPhone 3G S. I spent a weekend with my iPhone 3G S, capturing several video clips to see how well it works. So far, I am mostly impressed. The video capture and editing features are basic, but easy to use, and my video clips look decent.

To record videos on the iPhone 3G S, you open the camera (which has been bumped up to 3 megapixels on the new phone), and toggle the on-screen slider from the still camera icon to the video camera icon. Then, you just tap the red button to begin recording.

The 3.5-inch screen is spacious and clear, so seeing the video as you’re recording it is easy. The only problem I ran into was the position of the camera lens: When you’re looking at the back of the iPhone, the lens is in the upper-left corner. I found that I often accidentally draped my fingers in front of it when trying to capture videos.

Another bummer: The video controls on the iPhone 3G S are as basic as they come. You don’t get a zoom — or anything else for that matter. You can start and stop recording when you like, but that’s about it. After testing the Nokia N97 last week, which includes an on-screen zoom, as well as the ability to pause and resume recording, the iPhone 3G S’s video features felt extra skimpy.

My expectations about the iPhone’s video quality were low, since the device has never been known for having a great camera. But the video that the iPhone 3G S produced surprised me with its quality.

Clips were not as good as the videos I captured with the Nokia N97, but ranged from decent to good. The iPhone 3G S records VGA-resolution (640 by 480) at 30 frames per second, and my video clips looked clear and sharp, though a tad dark, when viewed on the iPhone screen. The audio captured was loud and clear, too. Video clips didn’t look quite as good when blown up on my computer screen, though.

The video editing tools available on the iPhone 3G S are so basic that it’s almost not fair to call them tools; all you can do is trim the length of the video. Still, this is probably the feature many iPhone users want most, and it’s very easy to use. When you play back your video on the iPhone 3G S, you’ll see a row of still images (frames from the video) above it. You can pick any of these images, which are points in the video, and mark one as the beginning of the video and another as the end by dragging the on-screen markets. Voila, your video is cropped. It really doesn’t get any easier than that.
trim_iphone_video
When you trim the video like this, though, you’re trimming the original file, and any frames you delete from the video are gone forever. So you should make sure you really want to make cuts before you do so, or at least, back up your videos to your computer first.

Transferring videos is easy, too. When you view a video on the phone, you have the option of sending it via e-mail or uploading it directly to YouTube. (If your videos are longer than one minute in length, though, you’ll have to trim them before sending them via e-mail.) If you have a MobileMe account, you can sync videos there. And once AT&T begins offering MMS on the iPhone, you should be able to share videos that way, too.

I’d love to see a zoom feature and a few more video-editing options on the iPhone. Until those kinds of features are added, the iPhone 3G S is not going to replace a dedicated video camera like the Flip. But, overall, I was pleasantly surprised with how well the video recording worked. I don’t think you should buy an iPhone 3G S just to record video clips, but if you were planning on buying one anyway, the video camera will just be an added bonus.

For more takes on the video capabilities, check out our sister blogs in the GigaOM network. Over at jkOnTheRun, Kevin took the new iPhone for a spin and generally liked what he saw (and recorded). But Dave at The Apple Blog ran into a whiny problem, well, he’s not whining, but the audio track on his recorded video is.

  1. “Video clips didn’t look quite as good when blown up on my computer screen, though.” what a surprise!

    sorry but this review feels like it should be in a high school mag not on newteevee, suggest you let the techy sites do camera reviews – they are good at it, you are good at analysing the newteevee scene

    Share
  2. I appreciated your review. Ignore that grumpy person.

    Share
  3. One limitation that I noticed with the iPhone Video Recording and I haven’t heard anyone mention is that recording is disabled while on a phone call!

    Not sure if this is considered a true limitation, but I find myself occasionally wanting to capture a video while talking to someone (with my bluetooth headset of course)..

    Share
    1. This is true, I’m glad you mentioned this, i thought my iPhone 3GS was broken, the video recording ability is disabled while in a voice phone call with someone and haven’t seen many talk about the limitation. But it makes sense, video is pointless if you’re speaking to someone, there would be no way to capture sound for the video if you’re speaking to someone on the line with one microphone.

      Share
  4. [...] Read the rest here:  iPhone 3G S Video Recording: Better Than Expected [...]

    Share
  5. i love the i phone 3g s!

    Share
  6. ok well this doesn’t help me to firgure out video when i do’t know what toggle means!!!!! if this is suppose to help people that don’t know how to use the phone it would help to be more descriptive!!!

    Share
  7. [...] Makes iPhone Video Uploads (Somewhat) Easier It’s great that the iPhone finally has the ability to record video, right? But once you’ve captured your video, the iPhone doesn’t allow you to do much [...]

    Share
  8. The problem is that the videos don’t sync in itunes like your pictures. So if you have to restore your phone, you can say goodbye to those videos.

    Share
    1. Where DO you find the videos once you sync the photos (with the “include videos” box checked)?

      Share
  9. AssholeonLog Tuesday, July 21, 2009

    iPhone 3G S is a POS like the other two iPhones. The video sucks. It’s late in the game with half of its features, yet people act like it’s the best phone ever just because it has a mountain of shitty apps.

    Morons…

    Share
  10. What´s the maximum length possible of video on 3gs?

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post