7 Comments

Summary:

Updated: Electric car maker Tesla Motors is no stranger to lawsuits, and now it’s been hit with an ugly one. In a 146-page complaint filed May 26 in San Mateo County Superior Court that we (and other news outlets) obtained yesterday, the ousted founder of Tesla […]

Updated: Electric car maker Tesla Motors is no stranger to lawsuits, and now it’s been hit with an ugly one. In a 146-page complaint filed May 26 in San Mateo County Superior Court that we (and other news outlets) obtained yesterday, the ousted founder of Tesla Motors, Martin Eberhard, alleges that Tesla CEO Elon Musk has both libeled and slandered him, and that the company has breached several agreements with Eberhard over severance, stock options and his purchase of a Roadster vehicle.

teslaroadstereberhardpost

The document is a painful play-by-play — from Eberhard’s perspective — of how the relationship between Musk and Eberhard went south, Eberhard left the company, and the aftermath. Part of Eberhard’s complaint is that Tesla and Musk have made untrue statements about him, including perpetuating the notion in the media (such as in this post we wrote) that Elon Musk is the founder of Tesla. Eberhard also alleges that Musk has disparaged him, both to the media and to Tesla employees.

Eberhard further alleges that he signed a severance agreement when he left Tesla, but that after he wrote a blog post about Tesla’s dismissal of employees, the company discontinued his severance payments, revoked his rights to vest stock options and dismissed him from the Tesla advisory board. Eberhard also alleges that Tesla breached the agreement he had in place to purchase the second Roadster in the founder series and instead sold that Roadster to Musk’s friend Antonio Gracias, and that the Roadster he eventually received (after it was crashed and repaired) was worth significantly less than the one in his agreement.

On top of all that, Eberhard makes additional claims, such as negligent infliction of emotional distress and an allegation that Musk has been inaccurately portraying his connection to Stanford University. Beyond the drama, it’s actually pretty interesting to hear Eberhard’s side of the story, given he’s been relatively quiet throughout this whole process.

Updated: Tesla’s spokesperson Rachel Konrad emailed us the company’s statement on Eberhard’s lawsuit:

This lawsuit is an unfair personal attack and, more importantly, paints an inaccurate picture of Tesla’s history. This lawsuit is a fictionalized account of Tesla’s early years — it’s twisted and wrong, and we welcome the opportunity to set the record straight. As the media have already covered exhaustively, Tesla’s full board of directors unanimously fired Martin shortly after discovering that the cost of the car was more than twice what Martin portrayed it to be at the time. Incidentally, Tesla will likely be filing counterclaims and in the process present an accurate account of the company’s history.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. Tesla CEO Fires Back at Founder, Says Will Respond In Court Soon Monday, June 22, 2009

    [...] No Comments Posted June 22nd, 2009 at 10:15 am in Automotive,Startups Welcome to Round 2 of the latest Tesla Motors feud. The electric car startup’s CEO, Elon Musk, has just written a post on the official company [...]

  2. Tesla Fires Back at Founder, This Time in Court Calling for Dismissal Tuesday, June 30, 2009

    [...] Eberhard’s lawsuit against the electric vehicle startup and its current CEO, Elon Musk, surfaced earlier this month, Tesla called the allegations of libel, slander and breach of contract “an unfair personal [...]

  3. Tesla Motors Claims $1M July Profit (a First!), Thanks to Roadster 2 Friday, August 7, 2009

    [...] up to be a bittersweet summer for Tesla Motors. While in June the electric car startup became embroiled in a lawsuit with founder Martin Eberhard, the Department of Energy also approved a long-awaited $465 million [...]

  4. Tesla Founder Drops Lawsuit Against Tesla & CEO Wednesday, August 19, 2009

    [...] Of all the twists and turns we might have expected to follow last month’s court decision that enabled ousted Tesla founder Martin Eberhard’s lawsuit against the electric car startup and CEO Elon Musk to proceed, this one has caught us by surprise: Eberhard has dropped the suit in which he made allegations of libel, slander and breach of contract against his former employer. [...]

  5. Tesla Founder Marc Tarpenning on How to Start a Car Company Thursday, August 27, 2009

    [...] Compared with Tesla Motors co-founder Martin Eberhard, the startup’s other founder — Marc Tarpenning — has kept a relatively low profile. But Tarpenning spoke this morning at IBM’s Almaden Institute 2009 in San Jose, Calif., telling his version of the Tesla creation story that Eberhard and CEO Elon Musk have been fighting over this summer. [...]

  6. Tesla Founder Marc Tarpenning on How to Start a Car Company « Energy Portfolio Managers Blog Monday, September 21, 2009

    [...] Compared with Tesla Motors co-founder Martin Eberhard, the startup’s other founder — Marc Tarpenning — has kept a relatively low profile. But Tarpenning spoke this morning at IBM’s Almaden Institute 2009 in San Jose, Calif., telling his version of the Tesla creation story that Eberhard and CEO Elon Musk have been fighting over this summer. [...]

  7. Earth2Tech’s Top 15 Connected Car Influencers Monday, January 25, 2010

    [...] all its delays, detours, financial hurdles and legal distractions, startup Tesla Motors has stuck around for seven years, launching in 2008 what’s still the [...]

Comments have been disabled for this post