10 Comments

Summary:

Amazon today started offering both movies and TV shows in HD, a welcome and rumored upgrade. I took the Video on Demand service out for a quick test drive, and found the HD video quality to be very good and the overall system simple to use. […]

Amazon today started offering both movies and TV shows in HD, a welcome and rumored upgrade. I took the Video on Demand service out for a quick test drive, and found the HD video quality to be very good and the overall system simple to use.

amazon_hd_screen

Amazon Video on Demand lets you rent or purchase movies and TV shows from its library of about 40,000 titles on your computer or from your TV, with the help of a compatible set-top box. Amazon didn’t provide a specific number of HD titles available but a press announcement said users can browse through “hundreds of selections.” Compatible devices include some TiVo DVRs, Roku’s Digital Video Player, Sony’s Bravia Internet Video Link and Panasonic Vieracast. Most titles will cost $1 more to rent or purchase in HD:  TV shows, which typically sell for $1.99 an episode in SD, will cost $2.99, and movies that go for $3.99 to rent in SD will cost $4.99 in HD.

I tested the HD streaming capabilities on Roku’s Digital Video Player, a small set-top box that also streams Netflix movies. You connect the $100 device to your TV and to your home network, either via Ethernet or wirelessly. From the comfort of your couch, you can browse all of the titles that Amazon has available, and can decide whether to rent or purchase a movie. (You will need to set up a pin online before making any purchases, though.)

I rented Tropic Thunder in HD, and viewed some of it while connected to my home network via Ethernet and some while connected wirelessly. When the Roku box was connected via Ethernet, the experience was a delight. The movie began playing almost instantly, and the picture looked nearly as sharp and clear as a Blu-ray movie or an HD title rented on demand from my cable company. It was a significant upgrade from an SD movie rented from Amazon, and also better quality than a Netflix title streamed in HD.

When I switched to a wireless connection, though, video quality degraded noticeably. The movie seemed to buffer a bit before starting, and the picture stuttered and broke up a few times. Even when I had the movie playing smoothly, the picture still never looked quite as sharp as it did when I had the Roku box connected via Ethernet. If my only option were to connect my Amazon-compatible device wirelessly, I don’t think I’d bother paying the extra $1 it costs to rent movies in HD as opposed to standard definition.

In both situations — wired and wireless — I fired up several computers on the same network, and had all of them streaming YouTube videos in HD. I noticed no performance hit on the Amazon movie at all, regardless of how much activity was taking place on my network. What might be of greater concern, though, is the amount of bandwidth you’ll be using, especially if your broadband provider is one of the many considering limiting the amount you use. I asked both Amazon and Roku if they knew the size of the files being streamed, but did not receive an answer in time for posting this. We’ll update with more information if we receive it.

If you already have a compatible Amazon streaming device, today’s announcement is a great news for you. But is it enough to make me run out and pick up one of those set-top boxes? Almost — but not just yet.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. Hi Liane, Interesting article but you left out some key information that is pertinent to you story:

    What type of TV do you have? Watching HD movies on an SD/ED set will make it look as good as Blu-Ray.

    What type of internet connection do you have? Most internet connections are limited by the 10baseT router/modem connection and not the 100baseT internal network. By not seeing a hit when d/l’ing multiple “HD” YouTube streams it could be because of buffering. Try and install a bandwidth monitor on the devices and see what the combined bandwidth consumption is.

    While an informative article, it seems a bit too anecdotal and a bit of a plug for the service.

    1. @Timekeeper,

      I tried the service out last night via my Roku on my 720p Samsung TV, and my experience mirrored Liane’s — for the most part. The picture quality was excellent… at first. Then 20 minutes into the movie (“Frost/Nixon”)(very good, btw), the film stopped, re-buffered and when it came back it dropped the HD.

      I wasn’t downloading anything else, I was using a wired connection, and nothing else connected to the network on, so there shouldn’t have been an issue from a bandwidth perspective. The irritating thing is that I paid for an HD movie — but only got SD. I’ve contacted Amazon to see what’s going and will update later.

  2. Amazon is Amazing! If only I had something to do with all my unread books I’d be fine

  3. Thanks for the update Chris. It’s funny how a few key bits of information can really set the stage. I’m assuming that you are using the HDMI interface.

    Isn’t that part of the streaming problem, inconstant bandwidth? There should be more local storage on the Roku to get around this.

    1. Yeah, bandwidth will be an issue (especially for houses with kids going online). I’ve watched a bunch of the Netflix streaming HD content and never experienced this problem.

  4. Second Take: Amazon HD VOD Not Ready for Prime Time? Tuesday, April 28, 2009

    [...] Take: Amazon HD VOD Not Ready for Prime Time? When Amazon released the HD version of its VOD service last week, the future of movie rentals seemed so close I could taste it. But while at first it was [...]

  5. Amazon lancia l’HD per alcuni suoi contenuti | NoNiente.com Thursday, April 30, 2009

    [...] L’HD arriva su Amazon. La famosa compagnia che si occupa di e-commerce arricchisce infatti il proprio catalogo di contenuti televisivi e cinematografici in alta definizione. [...]

  6. Why I Jumped on the Blu-ray Bandwagon Friday, May 1, 2009

    [...] Maybe we’re headed for an all-broadband, all-download and streaming world, one in which HD movies are sent directly to your TV. A world where you don’t have to wait for the coveted red Netflix envelope to land in your [...]

  7. Despite Econalypse – Internet Still Innovating « Connected Sunday, May 3, 2009

    [...] will hopefully maintain net neutrality. This is a necessity for WebTV as big name players such as Amazon and Hulu continue to make legal high quality content available to consumers. Original Webseries [...]

  8. Kodak’s Theater HD Player Needs Better Connections Friday, June 26, 2009

    [...] HD videos. Still, I’d like to see more online content — integration with Netflix or Amazon’s VOD service could really make the Kodak player [...]

Comments have been disabled for this post