13 Comments

Summary:

After we wrote on Thursday that AT&T had altered its terms of service to limit mobile video, the company changed its mind. AT&T let us know last night that it had reverted the TOS change. The language added on March 30 to AT&T’s wireless data service […]

After we wrote on Thursday that AT&T had altered its terms of service to limit mobile video, the company changed its mind. AT&T let us know last night that it had reverted the TOS change.

The language added on March 30 to AT&T’s wireless data service Terms and Conditions was done in error. It was brought to our attention and we have since removed it. We apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused.

But upon reading the new TOS this morning, we see that only one clause was removed from the two sections which seemed designed to inhibit mobile video — one a list of disallowed services, and the other a list of overage charges for mobile data.

Yesterday, the TOS forbid these things:

downloading movies using P2P file sharing services, customer initiated redirection of television or other video or audio signals via any technology from a fixed location to a mobile device, web broadcasting, and/or for the operation of servers, telemetry devices and/or Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition devices

Today, it forbids these:

downloading movies using P2P file sharing services, web broadcasting, and/or for the operation of servers, telemetry devices and/or Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition devices is prohibited.

The only revision is to remove the description of “customer initiated redirection of television…” — what companies like Sling Media and Orb Networks do.

What’s all the more pointed about this change is that AT&T offers a competing live Mobile TV service — for a charge of $15 or $30 per month. So it seems that while they were first trying to block the competition, the folks at AT&T (perhaps the people who pay their legal fees) had a change of heart. As for the rest of the stuff — P2P, web broadcasting — well, that’s still not allowed.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. I think they offer about three video/tv services. Streaming shows, streaming clips, and mediaflo – all for a fee, of course. And who knows if the streaming ones count against the cap like a Sling or Hava does.

  2. Brett Glass Sunday, April 5, 2009

    It’s perfectly reasonable for the provider to offer video at an extra charge but not otherwise. Video consumes large amounts of bandwidth, and can cause the provider to lose money on the customer each month. But if there’s a way to recover the extra cost via a surcharge, then it’s possible for the customer to get good value while the provider can at least break even. That’s a win/win.

  3. Brett, I pay both AT&T (phone) and Sprint (aircard) for data services. I’m perfectly fine with them capping usage (at 5GB). But telling me how I can or cannot use my quota is BS, and in this case perhaps anticompetitive. They made the right decision to roll it back. Although they’re not out of the woods yet – I’m hoping the FCC does indeed take a look at why Skype is limited to WiFi only on the iPhone.

  4. Going Cellular » AT&T alters TOS, retracts part of it Monday, April 13, 2009

    [...] AT&T retracted part of their TOS change, namely the part about Slingbox. They claim that the TOS change was “done in error,” [...]

  5. Carriers Aim to Keep Rural Broadband Under Their Thumb Friday, April 17, 2009

    [...] rejection of net neutrality could result in anti-competitive actions. Those actions may include blocking television redirection services from providers like Sling Media, which may be viewed as anti-competitive since carriers resell [...]

  6. AT&T Continues to Adjust TOS to Limit 3G Video Wednesday, April 29, 2009

    [...] Adjust TOS to Limit 3G Video AT&T has adjusted its terms of service again — after retracting parts of a previous revision — to limit uses of mobile data plans for video services like [...]

  7. AT&T Continues to Adjust TOS to Limit 3G Video [NewTeeVee] | BYOHosting.com Blogs Wednesday, April 29, 2009

    [...] has adjusted its terms of service again — after retracting parts of a previous revision — to limit uses of mobile data plans for video services like [...]

  8. New iPhone to Include Final Cut Pro HD — Just Kidding! Friday, May 1, 2009

    [...] nation status with AT&T to push that one through; just this week, the phone company (again!) changed its wireless data TOS to limit some uses of video. [...]

  9. MLB iPhone App to Live-Stream Games Over 3G; Still No Sling Thursday, June 18, 2009

    [...] 3G connection — unlike the Sling video-streaming app, which only works over Wi-Fi because of a clause in AT&T’s Terms of Service forbidding it. Because of this, the live video offering is [...]

  10. MLB iPhone App to Live-Stream Games Over 3G; Still No Sling | Design Website Easy Friday, June 19, 2009

    [...] 3G connection — unlike the Sling video-streaming app, which only works over Wi-Fi because of a clause in AT&T’s Terms of Service forbidding it. Because of this, the live video offering is [...]

Comments have been disabled for this post