28 Comments

Summary:

This morning’s Wall Street Journal reports that IBM is in talks to buy Sun Microsystems for $6.5 billion in cash. The deal makes sense given Sun’s distressed share price, and because both companies appear to be pursuing cloud computing — the next big computing opportunity — […]

This morning’s Wall Street Journal reports that IBM is in talks to buy Sun Microsystems for $6.5 billion in cash. The deal makes sense given Sun’s distressed share price, and because both companies appear to be pursuing cloud computing — the next big computing opportunity — in a similar manner. Let’s see how each plans to tackle the cloud.

Infrastructure: Sun announced today that it will offer cloud computing and cloud storage. IBM doesn’t have this, but in a chat yesterday, Drew Clark, director of strategy and corporate venture capital at IBM, told me that if IBM needed to offer infrastructure, it would. However, IBM doesn’t think it will be a high-value service. Buying rather than building it would make sense, especially if it can get it on the (relative) cheap.

Platform: Both IBM and Sun are working with startups to build out an open cloud computing platform to connect a variety of clouds, from Amazon’s to GoGrid’s to internal clouds. Sun is already working with RightScale and Zmanda to offer cloud services and management for its cloud and others. Clark outlined a similar strategy yesterday on behalf of IBM, and mentioned RightScale and Aptana, as other providers of the management layer for the cloud.

Software: Sun and IBM both have deals to provide their software inside other clouds, such as Amazon’s EC2. If a developer keeps using Solaris or DB2, no matter which cloud they’re using, that’s a win for IBM and Sun. It’s also a win for the infrastructure providers who get access to Solaris and DB2 customers who might have not used their service otherwise.

Business Process Services: I have no idea what Sun might offer here, but Clark has suggested that IBM will gain the most value from delivering services via the cloud, such as high performance computing. “We see cloud as a service, and IBM is a services company,” he said yesterday.

So, for $6.5 billion, IBM would get the underlying pieces to deliver those services and a partner that has made some strides in developing open standards and governance measures for the cloud (Sun even has a chief governance officer for the cloud). Freedom to move data around and a proven concern for security will appeal to IBM’s enterprise customers.

Outside of the cloud, IBM and Sun both offer corporate hardware that can be built using non-Intel hardware, such as Sparc chips from Sun or Cell and PowerPC chips from IBM. The biggest issues will likely come from Sun’s relaxed culture meeting IBM’s suit-and-tie atmosphere. But if IBM can harness the ideas that come out of Sun’s engineers and bring them to execution, the deal would benefit IBM greatly. I wonder if Johnathan Schwartz, Sun’s CEO and president, would have to cut his hair?

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. Obviously, people tend to have their hair well-trimmed when interviewed for a new job.
    Just kidding, but I’m not sure with Schwartz’s future position in eventually merged companies.
    Anyway, the big question remains over Sun’s MySQL currently competing against IBM’s DB2 at some levels. Will IBM fuse both technologies or position them at different market segments?

  2. This move makes lots of sense. It takes a services and implementation arm like IBM and the high capacity, high performance architecture of Sun to get cloud computing to the next level. There’s a place for “budget clouds” like Amazon EC2 and for “luxury clouds” like what will probably come from some of the big enterprise players.

  3. Jeffrey McManus Wednesday, March 18, 2009

    Cloud computing can’t possibly be on the list of reasons why IBM wants to purchase Sun, since Sun is a distant also-ran in the space. If they wanted to get it on the cheap, they’d just build it.

    1. Jeffrey it’s hard to say that anyone is an also-ran when it comes to delivering cloud to enterprise customers. Amazon got to the cloud first, but there’s a lot more to offer here, especially for enterprise customers.

      1. I guess my point is that Sun’s offering isn’t even an actual business yet, so there’s nothing in it for any prospective buyer.

  4. Why Cisco, Not IBM, Should Buy Sun Wednesday, March 18, 2009

    [...] Malik | Wednesday, March 18, 2009 | 9:00 AM PT | 0 comments With IBM rumored to have made a $6.5 billion buyout offer for Sun Microsystems, it appears the company that coined the phrase “The Network is the Computer” is in [...]

  5. With Cisco entering server market, this is to be expected. There is going to be some realignment in the industry, and this is a big step in that direction.

  6. IBM buying Sun is sooo last century. With Sun out of gas, who cares if IBM buys the company or it “winds down” like DEC. Doesn’t IBM have something innovative to do with all that money – like Apple and Google have? Read more at http://www.ThePhoenixPrinciple.com

  7. Such a day! « Tech Monkey Wednesday, March 18, 2009

    [...] reported today that IBM is in talks to acquire Sun. It will be a good deal to IBM. Despite a poorly managed turnaround, Sun still has a good package of products: servers and [...]

  8. Ashutosh Nilkanth’s Blog | Sun Among The Clouds Thursday, March 19, 2009

    [...] a brighter side to Sun’s cloud computing strategy for startups though. As Stacey Higginbotham wrote at GigaOm: Both IBM and Sun are working with startups to build out an open cloud computing platform [...]

  9. Oh… this is a definite strategic plan for IBM to gain server’s and storage’s market share greatly….. I think its a good buy

  10. Subbaraman Iyer Thursday, March 19, 2009

    I don’t think the acqusition makes sense. I have made my case at: http://subbaiyer.wordpress.com/2009/03/19/does-ibm-need-sun/

  11. IBM is in Talks to Buy Sun; the Logical Consequence of All-Out War for Data Center, Says WSJ | domain names | Thursday, March 19, 2009

    [...] IBM’s potential purchase of Sun: Here’s why it makes sense ZDNet, Mar.18.2009 Why IBM Should Buy Sun: Cloud Services GigaOm, [...]

  12. Elefantenhochzeit: IBM will Sun Microsystems übernehmen | TechFieber | Hot Gadgets. Smart TechNews. Saturday, March 21, 2009

    [...] Why IBM Should Buy Sun: Cloud Services Share and Enjoy: [...]

  13. Cloud compliance: Will PCI be applied to cloud computing by the FTC? – IT Compliance Advisor Monday, March 23, 2009

    [...] all, that IBM is in talks to buy Sun Microsystems. Why? GigaOm thinks IBM wants to bolster its cloud computing [...]

  14. Cisco’s Data Center Play Paves the Way for More M&A Tuesday, March 24, 2009

    [...] will compete with offerings primarily from HP and IBM. A few days later, rumors circulated that IBM might buy Sun Microsystems for $6.5 billion (or that maybe Cisco should). And as these tech titans fight for supremacy of the data center, at [...]

  15. IBM + Sun = Good, or Bad, for Green? Tuesday, March 24, 2009

    [...] Stacey has pointed out over at GigaOM, there’s a lot of potential for synergy between IBM and Sun’s cloud computing [...]

  16. I think it’d be a fantastic waste of $6.5B if cloud technology & support is all they want from Sun.

    I’m not saying there might not be other good reasons for them to want Sun’s technology (and technologists – more to the point) but I think that cloud on its own is not good enough reason.

    Sun is a once great company, and I enjoyed my time working for them. I think they need a massive restructuring of management to survive – I hope they can do that somehow.

  17. Sun-IBM Merger Hits A Snag Sunday, April 5, 2009

    [...] of engineering excellence. Stacey believes that the two companies, if combined, could become serious players in cloud computing. In March this year, Sun announced plans to sell its own cloud services. In my view, IBM is getting [...]

  18. Oracle To Buy Sun For $7.4 Billion Monday, April 20, 2009

    [...] Oracle found itself yet another bargain and in one wide sweep became a worthy competitor to IBM. It allows Oracle to become a player in the cloud computing business. More importantly, the company ends up acquiring MySQL, the upstart database that has been viewed [...]

  19. Oracle To Buy Sun For $7.4 Billion | Non Stop 24 Monday, April 20, 2009

    [...] Oracle found itself yet another bargain and in one wide sweep became a worthy competitor to IBM. It allows Oracle to become a player in the cloud computing business. More importantly, the company ends up acquiring MySQL, the upstart database that has been viewed [...]

  20. Oracle & Sun To Merge… Monday, April 20, 2009

    [...] Oracle found itself yet another bargain and in one fell swoop became a worthy competitor to IBM. It allows Oracle to become a player in the cloud computing business. More importantly, the company ends up acquiring MySQL, the upstart database that has been viewed [...]

  21. Oracle to Buy Sun (and MySQL) for $7.4B [GigaOM] | BYOHosting.com Blogs Monday, April 20, 2009

    [...] Oracle found itself yet another bargain and in one fell swoop became a worthy competitor to IBM. It allows Oracle to become a player in the cloud computing business. More importantly, the company ends up acquiring MySQL, the upstart database that has been viewed [...]

  22. Oracle to Buy Sun (and MySQL) for $7.4B [GigaOM] | BYOHosting.com Blogs Monday, April 20, 2009

    [...] Oracle found itself yet another bargain and in one fell swoop became a worthy competitor to IBM. It allows Oracle to become a player in the cloud computing business. More importantly, the company ends up acquiring MySQL, the upstart database that has been viewed [...]

  23. Open source community reacts to Oracle-Sun deal – Enterprise Linux Log Tuesday, April 21, 2009

    [...] found itself yet another bargain and in one fell swoop became a worthy competitor to IBM. It allows Oracle to become a player in the cloud computing business. More importantly, the company ends up acquiring MySQL, the upstart database that has been viewed [...]

  24. Technology thoughts on the Oracle-Sun Deal – if your into that kinda thing. : Jamie Jackson XP Thursday, May 14, 2009

    [...] Oracle found itself yet another bargain and in one fell swoop became a worthy competitor to IBM. It allows Oracle to become a player in the cloud computing business. More importantly, the company ends up acquiring MySQL, the upstart database that has been viewed [...]

  25. Open source community reacts to Oracle-Sun deal | Results videos photos news blogs At I google wiki . com Saturday, July 11, 2009

    [...] found itself yet another bargain and in one fell swoop became a worthy competitor to IBM. It allows Oracle to become a player in the cloud computing business. More importantly, the company ends up acquiring MySQL, the upstart database that has been viewed [...]

Comments have been disabled for this post