6 Comments

Summary:

Intel on Monday night filed suit to stop graphics chipmaker Nvidia from tying its graphics chips to certain future Intel CPUs. The suit filed in the Delaware Court of Chancery alleges that Nvidia doesn’t have the right to integrate a Nvida GPU with future Intel processors, […]

ci7x_78Intel on Monday night filed suit to stop graphics chipmaker Nvidia from tying its graphics chips to certain future Intel CPUs. The suit filed in the Delaware Court of Chancery alleges that Nvidia doesn’t have the right to integrate a Nvida GPU with future Intel processors, such as the high-end Core i7 chip code-named Nehalem, under a current licensing agreement between the two companies. The sealed suit also seeks to get Nvidia to stop telling its customers it can integrate its GPUs with certain Intel chips, an alleged breach of the agreement.

Apparently the two chipmakers have been fighting over this issue for a year, and Intel finally decided to take it to the courts to decide. Intel spokesman Chuck Mulloy says the suit has nothing to do with current Nvidia products such as the ION platform, which combines an Intel Atom processor with a Nvidia GPU, but whether or not Nvidia can tie its chips to Intel processors that contain integrated memory. Right now that means Intel’s Core i7 processor.

“We want the court to determine the rights of the parties under the agreement,” says Mulloy. “We have one view and they have another. We hope that this dispute doesn’t impact other areas of the companies’ working relationships.”

It looks like Nvidia’s attacks on the CPU and its efforts to push the GPU for general purpose computing are bearing fruit, since this is the first time Intel’s PR battle against Nvidia has made it to the courtroom. Industry watchers have wondered if Intel might try to stop Nvidia or netbook OEMs from using the ION platform, which might cut into higher-end Intel chip sales by creating a more notebook-like experience on the Atom chip.

Intel can’t stop Nvidia on all fronts, but it hasn’t been one to take its intellectual property or its near monopoly in x86 chips for granted — even if x86 computing is losing its ubiquity.  This looks like one way Intel is circling its wagons as PC sales drop, GPUs gain prominence, and it finds itself fighting for mobile market share against chipmakers pushing ARM-based chipsets.

  1. I think Intel needs to ask itself what the end game here is. If they actually start winning some of the recent suits that seek to consolidate their market power, they will have opened themselves up to Anti-trust. I really don’t think the current climate will be so lenient to monopoly as the previous 20 years. By winning, they may end up losing even more. Of course, breaking up Intel would be great for consumers, so maybe we should hope they do win and thus lose.

    Share
  2. I am concerned about the 2nd part where Intel says Nvidia allegedly breached their agreement.. Do they mean their current bus license agreement? If Intel wins, won’t that affect current chipset since a breach of the current agreement would void it. That would affect current Apple and ION… won’t it?

    Share
  3. [...] control of the x86 chips inside computers could hinder GPU rivals once Larrabee comes out, as those GPU makers may not have the appropriate licenses to tie their chips to Intel’s CPUs. But the PC will be just one small (and shrinking) battleground to keep x86 relevant, amid a more [...]

    Share
  4. [...] second IP licensing fight Intel has started in as many months. In February it went to court over a licensing dispute it has with Nvidia concerning the GPU-maker’s ability to tie its graphics chips to Intel’s latest CPUs. [...]

    Share
  5. [...] second IP licensing fight Intel has started in as many months. In February it went to court over a licensing dispute it has with Nvidia (NVDA) concerning the GPU-maker’s ability to tie its graphics chips to Intel’s latest [...]

    Share
  6. [...] Nvidia, which is fighting with Intel seeking to ensure that its graphics processors work with Intel’s next-generation chips, the investigation is a welcome one. Nvidia, a relatively new rival for Intel,  would like to make [...]

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post