6 Comments

Summary:

I was surprised when I first learned that the Blackberry Storm would not have Wi-Fi. This was especially surprising to me since the other recent new Blackbery, the Bold, does have Wi-Fi.  It seems more and more of the upper-tier smartphones include this feature, and it […]

I was surprised when I first learned that the Blackberry Storm would not have Wi-Fi. This was especially surprising to me since the other recent new Blackbery, the Bold, does have Wi-Fi. 

It seems more and more of the upper-tier smartphones include this feature, and it got me wondering if it should be a feature a potential user should insist on. For me it definitely is.

Keep in mind that if you think Wi-Fi as just a high-speed data pipe, then I believe you’re underrating what Wi-Fi can do for your device. Here is why I’d insist on Wi-Fi in what, let’s face it, are hand-held computers that happen to make phone calls.

I Have My Own Network, Thanks

If you’ve put a high-speed network in your home, why shouldn’t you be able to add your device to it? Why send all your data through Verizon, or AT&T, or whoever when you have your own? To be sure, at most points in the chain you don’t have any control, but where you do have control, why not exercise it? 

Speed

No matter how fast your 3G connection is, a good Wi-Fi implementation will beat it. Probably handily, and in many cases by a wide margin. Why should your device not be allowed to take advantage of this speed? And this applies not only when you’re at home, but also at the many Wi-Fi hotspots throughout the country. 

No “Data Clock”

Even if you have “unlimited” access on your data plan, many carriers still impose limits (i.e., “unlimited” doesn’t really mean unlimited). By putting the device on a Wi-Fi network you not only get faster speed, you get off the carrier’s data clock. 

Battery

Wi-Fi access takes less juice than 3G, extending your device’s battery life.  

Applications

Perhaps more important than anything above are the kinds of applications your device can support when it becomes part of your local network. Below are just three examples from the iPhone that show what can be done.

Remote — Apple’s own remote app lets you control iTunes music playing and remote speakers throughout your system. This is a great example of the convenience you can get with devices on the same network. 

Air Sharing — Get on your network, then mount your iPhone as a local drive to your Mac. Now just copy files back and forth. Wonderful!

ACTPrinter — Get on your network and “print” to your iPhone. 

There are many other examples on the App Store as well, and they’re likely only scratching the surface of the potential a hand-held computer has when residing on your personal network. 

Summary

The point is that Wi-Fi opens up a smart device to a world of different applications that are not nearly as practical (or maybe even possible) when it’s limited to a specific carrier’s network. 

If you think of Wi-Fi as simply a speed increase (though it’s worth it for that, too), then I believe your thinking is short-sighted for this new generation of devices.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. No wifi on Storm because its on Verizon. Probably the same reason you don’t see the iPhone on Verizon.

  2. E,

    I think Verizon had a lot to do with it (though at some point RIM had to say “yes”), but for purposes of this article it doesn’t matter. No matter the reason for its absence, I believe any high-end smartphone without WiFi is severely lacking.

  3. I think a big reason WiFi was left off the Storm is to force Verizon users to purchase an Internet access plan. At least with the iPhone, 1st generation buyers who bought the phone on Apple.com but didn’t activate it with AT&T would still have the opportunity to use Wifi after activating and unlocking it.

    Now, if you buy the Storm off of eBay, you would be free to activate it (presumably) with Verizon, but without a data plan, how would you get Internet access on the device?

  4. I agree 100%. I was running an unlocked iPhone for several months before Unicel was bought up by Verizon. I decided it would be easy just to switch to Verizon and I was curious about trying a Blackberry. Well I had limited service at my house so there was no way I could do anything on my BB because it wouldn’t let me get online. I canceled Verizon and am now happily Wi-fiing it up on my iPhone with At&T. I would say that the lack of wi-fi was actually a deal breaker.

    Verizon needs to wake up, their network is very very good, but it’s just not better than wi-fi.

  5. It Must Be Nice to Be Verizon Monday, July 20, 2009

    [...] must be nice to disable hardware features on many phones, such as Bluetooth, GPS, and Wi-Fi, with little complaint from the [...]

  6. It Must Be Nice to Be Verizon » Shai Perednik.com Monday, July 20, 2009

    [...] must be nice to disable hardware features on many phones, such as Bluetooth, GPS, and Wi-Fi, with little complaint from the [...]

Comments have been disabled for this post