3 Comments

Summary:

Twitter says it’s stopped sending out tweets via SMS in the UK, claiming the popularity of the service has made the cost too prohibitive (bu…

imageTwitter says it’s stopped sending out tweets via SMS in the UK, claiming the popularity of the service has made the cost too prohibitive (but I’m still getting messages). Without Twitter actually having figured out a business model yet, it was always destined to be this way. Though it has struck carrier relationships in the US, Canada and India, co-founder Biz Stone said it could cost $1,000 per user per year to send elsewhere: “When you send one message to Twitter and we send it to 10 followers, you aren’t charged ten times – that’s because we’ve been footing the bill.” Seems obvious really.

After some digging, we found a big part of the problem may be Twitter’s choice of UK SMS distributor. Its UK-bound messaging is handled by Manx Telecom, an O2 subsidiary that operates telecoms on the Isle Of Man. Though phone calls between the UK and the Channel Islands are capped to cost the same as those within the mainland, SMS rates are unregulated so Isles telcos are free to set higher termination rates for those they send, Ofcom told us. The mobile networks are likely to pass these extra costs on to clients like Twitter; some of them even bill Channel Islands numbers at international rates. An O2 spokesperson was unable to confirm whether the telco had spoken with Twitter directly.

It looks like Twitter should maybe look for a mainland SMS aggregator, though, frankly, many other companies, including the BBC, already use the Isle Of Man gateway, so perhaps the problem lays more with the economics of Twitter itself. This is just the latest part of the Twitter service to bite the dust – the instant messenger link was recently shut off, too – but the Uk closure is a particular blow because Twitter is said to be growing faster in the UK than the US.

Twitter first got spooked about the problem when it capped UK SMSes at 250 per week in November, but the site has raised $15 million VC since then, taking it up to $20 million. If that money isn’t going in to carrier fees, where exactly is it going?

Tricia adds: A plan is in the works for UK Twitters to still get texts. The big catch is that they’ll have to pay for them. A company called Zygo said it will be launching a service called Zygotweet around September for non-U.S. and non-Indian users, to allow users to forward their tweets to cellphones. The person receiving the tweets will pay and will have to have an account with Zygo, which can be topped off with more credits as you receive more messages. The company’s original service, called ZygoHubs was to provide group SMS services to private groups and small businesses, but who’s to blame them for being opportunistic in an instance like this?

  1. [cross-commented from the Guardian]

    Not sure if the users discussing this issue at smstextnews.com are right, but it seems that companies like Twitter choose Manx Telecom precisely because SMS rates are unregulated: Twitterers tweeting by sending an SMS to Twitter via Manx Telecom seem to be paying more than they would for a normal UK SMS. It's a quasi-premium rate service that just looks like a normal rate service. And most probably, premium rate rules apply — the company gets a share of the revenue.

    Share
  2. Before this announcement I was looking into why I was suddenly being charged international rates to send texts to what looked like a standard UK number. I also asked different networks for their pricing policy and reasons behind it. Three networks gave three different answers. It's detailed on my blog.

    Twitter were less than open about this when challenged, preferring to say "check with your mobile operator about charges" when they should have said "our UK number is based in the Isle Of Man, not in the mainland UK – check with your provider that you won't be charged international rates". The way Twitter has handled these issues reflects poorly on them.

    A company called TweetSMS (http://www.tweetsms.com/) is also setting up a service to offer SMS functionality. It will be nice to receive Twitter updates by SMS but I'm not paying international rates to send Twitter updates by SMS.

    Right now my continued use of Twitter hangs in the balance.

    Share
  3. Some further digging perhaps. The Isle of Man is not part of the UK. It's a Crown Dependency and therefore sets its own taxes and legislation. It is also not a part of the Channel Islands, something which the article infers.

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post