7 Comments

Summary:

Following a petition filed with the Federal Communications Commission by Intel and Verizon requesting that Ethernet ports be required on the backs of set-top boxes, the National Cable and Telecommunications Association have come out in favor of an open standard such as Ethernet (or even better, […]

Following a petition filed with the Federal Communications Commission by Intel and Verizon requesting that Ethernet ports be required on the backs of set-top boxes, the National Cable and Telecommunications Association have come out in favor of an open standard such as Ethernet (or even better, the tru2way standard developed by the cable companies) but against any sort of federal mandates. The trade group filed an ex parte filing with the FCC last night in which it argued that industry groups could work together to figure out how to deliver digital content without any pesky government interference.

The effort to put Ethernet ports on cable boxes would be a boon to carriers delivering content via their own IP networks and to companies such as Intel that are trying to get Wi-Fi as the home networking standard of choice. Anyone inclined to point out that they can already connect their set-top box to devices via Firewire, HDMI, optical ports and coax, and hence to ask why Ethernet is necessary, may not realize the stakes at play when it comes to controlling digital content in the home.

Most vendors, be they carriers, networking gear makers or computer manufactures, view the set-top box as the key to digital content for consumers as ports will dictate how easy it is for consumers to plug their boxes into a variety of networks without adaptors. So as the computer industry and the telecommunications companies get deeper into the digital TV and home networking market, we’ll wait to see if the FCC decides to make Ethernet ports mandatory. Even if they do, a showdown between those in favor of Ethernet and those on the side of cable’s tru2way standard is likely to ensure as each industry seeks to control the home network.

image courtesy of Chris Albrecht

  1. [...] How Many Ports Does a Set-Top Box Need? Following a petition filed with the Federal Communications Commission by Intel and Verizon requesting that Ethernet ports be required on the backs of set-top boxes, the National Cable and Telecommunications Association have come out in favor of an open standard such as Ethernet (or even better, the tru2way standard developed by the cable companies) but against any sort of federal mandates. The trade group filed an ex parte filing with the FCC last night in which it argued that industry groups could work together to figure out how to deliver digital content without any pesky government interference. For more on the brewing battle between Ethernet and tru2way, check out the full story at GigaOM. [...]

    Share
  2. How many set top boxes do you need? None – connect your PC to your TV with a $20 cable. Zipityzap dot com.

    Share
  3. The Cisco acquisition of Pure and Scientific Atlanta are looking smarter and smarter all the time.

    Share
  4. Broadcasters are still trying to keep the control of the interactive content, but Internet (wire or wireless) is the rigth path for that. With tru2way you can only interact with your broadcaster, Internet is open to every content or application provider. What we need is a standard for web contents and TV integration.

    Share
  5. I’d say the less ports the better. I think that all Set Top Boxes should come standard with Wifi. Though putting Ethernet on set top boxes sounds great in practice, it is of limited use, unless you happen to have your router/hub nearby.

    Getting your wife to agree to let you have an Ethernet cable running across your living room floor is going to be a lot trickier than configuring wifi. Options such as power line internet are available to solve this problem, but they are currently still too expensive for casual users.

    Share
  6. Amazing. I’m in the pro-ethernet column; but, I’m astounded that folks here seem never to have heard of using wireless connections to their entertainment center.

    Even before my last step up to 80211.n, I used g just fine to download some of the evening’s content to my AppleTV. 80211.n just makes the download faster.

    Even the V 1.0 AppleTV HD is large enough for a few hours of HDTV.

    And my DirecTV HD-DVR already has an ethernet port which most use with a gamers’ wireless bridge to load content in the same manner.

    Ethernet should rule – because it’s still the connection of choice for home networks and, after all, that can and will be an essential link for home entertainment.

    Share
  7. I think this is the better concept that all set box is highly developed with wifi…………………

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post