[qi:014] I love the irony of the FCC and its complete and utter lack of rationality. It continues to show its Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde personality. The very same week it allows two satellite radio companies — Sirrus & XM — to merge, overlooking its very own reservations, promoting monopoly in that business, it is telling Comcast to stop messing around with P2P traffic. There will be no fines for Comcast for blocking the traffic.
Now you know I don’t care much for Comcast’s traffic managing ways — having written about it time and again — but this just seeks like an opportunistic and populist-baiting move from an organization that has lately stopped putting people first and started bowing and kneeling to large corporations, instead. And why pick on just Comcast? Why not go after other players like Cox as well? Why doesn’t FCC intervene in the metered Internet issue – that isn’t good for consumers either. Does anyone else feel that FCC has started to display a bizzare streak that shames Roger Clemens?
“Promoting monopoly”, my ass.
Apart from the 800lb gorilla which is terrestrial radio, consolidated as all-get-out as it is, the merged Sirius-XM has to compete with terrestrial digital, internet radio, and podcasting – and that’s just for ad money. The listening pool’s also being ever-more diluted by off-radio listening in cars.
You’re an extremely smart person. Probably best not to give the opposite impression by writing about nonexistent radio monopolies without even thinking about it or — worse — parroting the NAB’s current lobbying cribnotes.
FCC is just “starting to” display a bizarre streak?
I wrote a state of the US telecom post below …most has happened under the watch of the FCC the last few years
http://dealarchitect.typepad.com/deal_architect/2008/06/us-telecom-industry-unfairly-maligned.html
The most bizarre feature of the rumored Comcast decision is the demand that Comcast stop throttling P2P and to also tell the FCC how it’s been managing its network. First the hanging, then the trial.
@Richard…. Are you surprised by this hanging-first approach? Most politically compromised-motivated decisions are like that. FCC has become increasingly useless in that sense.
The FCC seems to be harder on cable than other industries like sat radio and the telecoms (where it has regulatory authority). I’m not seeing anything different here.
[...] FCC Rules Against a Baby Bell — Not only did the FCC decide on Friday to berate Comcast for messing with P2P traffic, but apparently it showed no love to Qwest, either, denying [...]
[...] appears that messing with P2P traffic, the likely enforcement order from the FCC and worries over tiered broadband have done little to dissuade people from moving to cable [...]
[...] 1, 2008 at 9:01 AM PT Comments (0) As expected, the Federal Communications Commission voted to chastise Comcast for its network management practices, with two commissioners of the five dissenting. Unfortunately, the FCC has decided not to [...]
[...] Higginbotham | Monday, January 5, 2009 | 12:36 PM PT | 0 comments Comcast, which got in trouble with the FCC for its P2P-throttling approach to network management, has now completed its plan that deals with [...]
[...] views about all this network shaping are pretty clear, as outlined earlier when Comcast started to mess with P2P traffic. FCC ruled against Comcast and eventually it was proven that Comcast was messing with even legal [...]
[...] a server platform and a series of software tools to measure broadband speeds, whether or not your ISP is filtering BitTorrent traffic and a diagnostic tool for last-mile problems. Coming soon are tests to help a user figure out of [...]
[...] views on all this network shaping are pretty clear, as outlined earlier when Comcast started to mess with P2P traffic. The FCC ruled against Comcast and eventually it was proven that Comcast was messing with even [...]
[...] it’s time to check out Google’s “Diagnostic” tools. The recent landmark ruling against Comcast bodes well for Boxee and democracy of information, but it’s certainly not the last battle [...]
[...] a server platform and a series of software tools to measure broadband speeds, whether or not your ISP is filtering BitTorrent traffic and a diagnostic tool for last-mile [...]
[...] Inspection: The End of the Internet as We Know It?” highlights the use of DPI equipment by Comcast in throttling P2P traffic, in Cox’s traffic prioritization scheme, the role DPI played in NebuAd’s plans to [...]
[...] DPI has been used by companies such as NebuAd to track surfing habits in order to serve up ads, and Comcast in order to block P2P packets. The technology isn’t evil, but its implementations have been questionable. [...]
[...] DPI has been used by companies such as NebuAd to track surfing habits in order to serve up ads, and Comcast in order to block P2P packets. The technology isn’t evil, but its implementations have been [...]
[...] of Columbia today ruled that the Federal Communications Commission didn’t have the authority to censure Comcast for throttling peer-to-peer packets, and also called into question the FCC’s ability to regulate broadband as a service. The move not [...]
[...] Columbia today ruled that the Federal Communications Commission didn’t have the authority to censure Comcast for throttling peer-to-peer packets, and also called into question the agency’s ability to regulate broadband as a service. The [...]
[...] was tied to the previous FCC’s one moment of consumer advocacy — its decision to censure Comcast for blocking P2P files on its [...]
[...] ironically, was tied to the previous FCC’s one moment of consumer advocacy: its decision to censure Comcast for blocking P2P files on its [...]
[...] when it comes to network neutrality by blocking peer-to-peer content on its network. It eventually earned a slap on the wrist from the Federal Communications Commission for its actions. As a result, it changed its network management practices to avoid discriminating [...]
[...] on its network as part of its network management practice. The FCC under Chairman Kevin Martin censured Comcast for blocking such files and ordered it to implement and file a new and non discriminatory network [...]
[...] it was found to be blocking BitTorrent on its network. The FCC ultimately lost that fight, after it censured Comcast for blocking the files only to have an appeals court tell the regulatory agency that it had no authority to dictate what [...]