19 Comments

Summary:

After playing around with the Roku Netflix streaming box review unit this weekend, I was ready to plunk down 99 of my hard-earned dollars to get one, even though Microsoft has announced that my Xbox 360 will soon do the same thing. And while everyone keeps […]

After playing around with the Roku Netflix streaming box review unit this weekend, I was ready to plunk down 99 of my hard-earned dollars to get one, even though Microsoft has announced that my Xbox 360 will soon do the same thing. And while everyone keeps focusing on the negatives of the Netflix streaming service on either box, it seems that they actually work the way TV should.

This fall, Xbox users (with a gold Xbox Live membership) will be able to access the 10,000 titles Netflix makes available to “Watch Instantly” on their TV sets. Just like the Roku, Xbox will stream the content, though unlike the Roku, Xboxes have a hard drive that could be possibly be used for downloading content at some point.

Yes, the gripes about Netflix’s service are all true. That “10,000 titles” stat is awfully misleading as most of those films are crap. The service is not in HD (though it still looked great), and on my HD TV, the colors all looked washed out.

So what, I freaking love that little Roku. And even better — my wife loved it (the first test for any set-top box).

It took two minutes to set up, it was easy to navigate and there were no hiccups during a marathon Friday Night Lights viewing session that ate up most of the weekend. And truth be told, I think that Roku is probably a better option than the NetfliXbox. It’s smaller, quieter (the Xbox cooling fan is annoyingly loud), and so, so easy to use.

But what the Roku really does is open your eyes to what the future of television should be. Pay a monthly subscription, watch what you want, when you want.

Sure, right now Netflix’s vision of the future of video entertainment is mostly bargain basement B-movies. The company has to know this is a problem and is hopefully working on a solution. So take off your hater pants and put on your happy, optimistic ones. It’s 10,000 titles now, but what about when that number grows to 100,000 or a million? It’s all there to watch as much as you like. Watch episodes of 30 Rock on your big TV set, where it looks good, and you don’t have to pay $1.99 for each episode or take up any hard drive space.

Mark Cuban suggested today that the video cloud should move from the last mile onto the existing TV distribution node. There the content could be transcoded to the right format to fit your TV, as well as be beamed via existing channels.

This, he argues, would save on bandwidth and could even eliminate the need for a personal DVR. It’s a good idea, and the Roku is a good first step in this direction. Netflix stores all the content, you just access it when you want. But the streaming issues need to be solved because while it worked well for me, others have reported bigger bandwidth issues. Plus I’m not interested in Comcast jacking up my ISP fees for using the Internet to get movies instead of its VOD service.

I don’t necessarily agree with Cuban’s assertion that coordination between video sites and distributors would be easy. If cable and satellite companies’ previous behavior is any indication, their ability to play nice and create an easy system for enjoying web video is unlikely to turn out the way we might be hoping.

Regardless, through the Roku I’ve gotten a first taste of my video future and can’t wait to see what’s to come.

  1. [...] flaws, but so does the Xbox, as more than one person has pointed out (Christ Albrecht of NewTeeVee still likes the Roku server a [...]

    Share
  2. I love the direction that media’s been taking lately. We just put our Netflix on hold to save money, but I have a feeling that by the time we get it back, there will be all sorts of amazing new features to try out.

    Share
  3. I’m kinda thinking now that I might need a Roku box, Chris…

    Share
  4. [...] NBC, ABC, FOX NBC Adds TVs, Movies to Xbox; in addition to Netflix content, Microsoft will be getting The Office (take that, Apple). (Wired [...]

    Share
  5. I just got a Roku box and I, like Chris, really love it. The colors do not look washed out on my 42″ HDTV, and in fact, the picture quality in general is quite good (better than I anticipated). I’d say it’s better than watching standard def programing from cable (at least Time-Warner Cable in Los Angeles, which is bad beyond belief). The lack of a lot of decent programming is a problem, but clearly NetFlix must realize this, so within 6 months, hopefully, this service should improve its library of offerings. At that point, the $99 will be easy to justify and I can see widespread use of this device, at least in the short term. Apple TV’s quality is better, but who is going to pay $1.99 ala carte and watch 6 episodes of 30 Rock in a row, like we did last night and fork out $12? Selection aside, this is a fantastic device. I’m happy with my purchase and it really does take 5 minutes to set up.

    Share
  6. Bout time ROKU caught up with the times. FyreTV already has this delivery with great quality and 20,000 movies. The only thing is…it’s all porn. I’ve seen it and its pretty awsome. Looks like ROKU will have the same for mainstream hollywood. Good bye video stores!

    Share
  7. Forget the box. Hook your TV up your laptop. All you need is a $20 cable. I’ll be posting details next week on Zipityzap.

    Share
  8. Chris Albrecht Tuesday, July 15, 2008

    Hey Geraldz,

    That might be a good solution for some, but I don’t really want to haul out the laptop each time, and I know my wife doesn’t. The Roku is the first TV gadget that she actually loves.

    Share
  9. Stacey Higginbotham Tuesday, July 15, 2008

    Chris, I too liked the Roku box, but after two weeks had nothing left to watch. Not sure how many people want to spend $99 on two weeks worth of entertainment based on the promise of more titles coming soon. Plus, then it sits in your cabinet taking up space, albeit just a small amount.

    Share
  10. [...] entertainment hubs. Sony’s announcement comes just a day after Microsoft said that it was hooking up with Netflix to stream movies to the Xbox. The NetfliXbox is like a buffet; users can stream all they want for [...]

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post