21 Comments

Summary:

About two months ago, I wrote about my decision to get rid of my land line and rely strictly on my cell phone — with its unlimited plan — for my voice needs. It was a mistake. My social network (namely in the form of my […]

About two months ago, I wrote about my decision to get rid of my land line and rely strictly on my cell phone — with its unlimited plan — for my voice needs. It was a mistake. My social network (namely in the form of my mother-in-law) couldn’t take it, so my husband and I capitulated and returned to AT&T for a basic land line with no frills for about $20 a month.

I should note that when we lost the land line, neither my husband nor I really noticed. There was one awkward moment when I had to send a fax and realized I couldn’t unless I went down the street to the grocery store, but other than that, I never missed the cord. My mother-in-law, on the other hand, a wonderful woman who still carries around a copy of the Yellow Pages in her car for when she needs to look up a number or an address, was very uncomfortable with the idea.

Since she regularly comes over to watch our daughter, and never charges her cell-phone battery, I saw her logic. And it got me to thinking about babysitters in general, and the possibility that we may one day hire one who didn’t have a cell phone (hey I suppose it could happen). More likely would be a case of bad reception, but if that coincided with any sort of emergency, they’d essentially be left incommunicado. It just seemed safer and easier to keep a cheap, dedicated land line.

To me it’s an important reminder that technology is essentially about linking us to one another (and being able to carry 10,000 songs in a gadget smaller than a cigarette case). To really make it work, your friends and family have to participate as well. That’s obvious on a social networking site, but less so when it comes to hardware and networking. For when I tried to cut the cord, my family wouldn’t let me

photo from wikiHow

Related research

Subscriber Content
?
Subscriber content comes from Gigaom Research, bridging the gap between breaking news and long-tail research. Visit any of our reports to learn more and subscribe.
By Stacey Higginbotham
  1. I pay Comcast monthly for the exact same reason. Couldn’t live with myself if there was an emergency and the babysitter had no way to call.

    Share
  2. Get a prepaid cell and put it in house.

    Share
  3. Good point. I currently don’t have a land line, and don’t miss it, but then I don’t have kids either and my entire family has AT&T cellphones. It just goes to show that each person needs to make a choice based on their individual situation, not because lots of people are doing the same thing (case in point: getting rid of cable and relying on the net and DVDs).

    Share
  4. I had a similar situation in that my wife wanted to ditch the landline. We have 3 young children (all under 5). Our oldest is now able to dial 911 – we know this from experience… :) My concern was if one of us were traveling and something happened to the other parent watching the kids, would our kids be able to find our cell phone if it was in our coat pocket or we forgot it in the car?

    The other option is to leave a phone plugged in because even if you don’t have service, you are supposed to be able to call 911.

    Share
  5. huuh, why dump the land line? You can’t get broadband without the land line and telephony is included in the broadband charge, so why bother. Plus the costs of a mobile phone are prohibitively expensive and you’re running up the costs for everyone who wants to call you.

    Oh wait, you live in the US. Where broadband is expensive and doesn’t include many of the standard things we have in the EU, but where mobile calls now can have unlimited calling and data usage, which results in americans using their mobiles 5-10 times more than in the EU.

    I wonna live in Singapore, where mobile phones are cheap, fibre is rolled out everywhere and there is no gum on the street.

    Share
  6. In Los Angeles, cellphone 911 goes to California Highway Patrol and the wait can be 15 minutes. ALthough I’ve heard land-based 911 isn’t much faster.

    Share
  7. To earn $20 a month from an investment that returns 5%, you’d need to invest $4800. There’s lots of things you can do with $4800 no?

    Might I suggest:
    a) buy another charger for your mother-in-law and leave it at your house
    or
    b) When you and your husband go out together, leave one of your cellphones at home
    or
    c) Buy the cheapest pre-paid cellphone you can find (is that still more than $20?)

    Share
  8. We have been landline-free for over five years. We have n people in the house and n+1 cellphones on a family plan. The extra phone sits in a cradle that Nokia used to make that combines a charger with powered speakers. So we always know where at least one phone is, it’s always charged, and it functions nicely as a speakerphone. Plus, we always have a spare cellphone for a babysitter or out of town guests.

    Share
  9. I use a landline for strictly E911. No sense in having the 911 operator trying to ask you where you are, plus I’ve noticed cell phones in this area route to the city next door (Bellevue) so you have to wait to get transferred to the proper 911 in Seattle.

    -matt

    Share
  10. Stacey Higginbotham Tuesday, April 29, 2008

    I’m diggin’ the pre-paid cell phone idea. I’ll have to run it by my mother-in-law, but maybe that would work. Alex I view my phone as a service, not an investment. But it still hurts to spend $240 a year.

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post