1 Comment

Summary:

Screen legend W.C. Fields is purported to have refused to work with children or animals, as they have a habit of stealing the show and upstaging the star. Will Ferrell, Adam McKay and his daughter Pearl proved Field’s caution is as relevant today as it was […]

Screen legend W.C. Fields is purported to have refused to work with children or animals, as they have a habit of stealing the show and upstaging the star. Will Ferrell, Adam McKay and his daughter Pearl proved Field’s caution is as relevant today as it was then, with The Landlord doing more to get Ferrell and McKay’s project in the public eye than a million press releases ever could.

This week, a cute-as-a-button toddler offering her surprisingly lucid plot synopsis of George Lucas’ classic space melodrama, Star Wars according to a 3-year-old piled up 3.8 million views and counting. For some perspective, that’s nearly as many people who tuned into Quarterlife‘s prime-time debut on NBC. The clip makes this viral video thing look easy, but don’t be fooled — it’s been staged to perfection.

This video response from RawVegas.tv, “Star Wars according to a 3-year-old” parody deconstructs the original clip smartly (and picked up 50,000 views in the process). It’s all in the editing. But what’s not addressed is the ethical concerns over publishing video of a child online before they’ve reached an age capable of informed consent — which commenters on the original clip voiced.A similar debate raged in the video blogging community back in November when long-time vlogger Michael Verdi posted a piece, Because Why Not? with his daughters being typically petulant children as he plays the doting parent. A flame war broke out in the comments and on the videoblogging group list, prompting a response video from Verdi and his daughters.

So while kids made great subjects, and work cheap, make sure you don’t put them in a position to hate you for it later. The kid who got the fake Xbox 360 for Christmas, and had his reaction filmed? I’m betting he ends up with some issues.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. I think it may be worth noting the addendum that the Star Wars kid poster added to the video description in the last day or two, which I’ve copy-pasta’d below…

    02/26/08 Update: Wow. What was expected to be a short movie that would circulate within a small circle of friends has turned into something much more very quickly. I’m thrilled that so many people have enjoyed this video but also somewhat mortified that I added this without my daughter’s knowledge or consent. Maybe someday she will find some humor in it.

    Comments: Have been disabled. I think they have run their course. To those who have sent positive comments, thank you very much. You’ve made us appreciate what we have even more than we already do. To those of you who’ve said you’ve changed your mind about having children, well, have at it. :)

    Business inquiries/agents: Thanks for your interest. At the current time we have no intention of exposing our little one to the destroyer of youth that is the entertainment industry. Hopefully if she chooses to follow this path on her own someday she will find a door still open for her.

    Other things:

    She has never seen Pokemon so I don’t think she’s making a reference to the ball on that show. I think she just means pokey ball as in “a ball that is pokey.” (And yes, I know what the pokey balls really are! Stop emailing :) )

    Three year olds can’t read. I’m sure there are exceptions to that rule.

Comments have been disabled for this post