8 Comments

Summary:

We’ve been hearing about stealthy fuel-cell startup Oorja Protonics, since word got out in mid-2006 that the company was one of Sequoia’s first cleantech investments. Well, after recently surveying Sequoia’s potential killer cleantech batting average, and chatting with Sequoia partner Pierre Lamond, we thought we’d take […]

We’ve been hearing about stealthy fuel-cell startup Oorja Protonics, since word got out in mid-2006 that the company was one of Sequoia’s first cleantech investments. Well, after recently surveying Sequoia’s potential killer cleantech batting average, and chatting with Sequoia partner Pierre Lamond, we thought we’d take a closer look at the Fremont, Calif.-based startup, which is making methanol-based fuel cells.

Oorja Protonic’s CEO Sanjiv Malhotra tells us that the company’s methanol fuel cells have a power range of .5 kilowatts to 5 kilowatts, and that initially, the company will target the battery market. Malhotra calls that power range the “sweet spot,” and says that compared to methanol fuel cells currently under development for consumer electronics, Oorja’s fuel cells will be “20 to 100 times more powerful.”

The company’s key technology is making the fuel cell that is powerful, but in a more compact system. So basically a very high-power density. While Malhotra says the company isn’t targeting vehicle batteries, an interesting application in that space could be for “material handling” for something like a forklift.

A major hitch for fuel cell technology has been that it seems perpetually a couple years away. Companies like MTI are developing methanol-based fuel cells for consumer electronics, and working with manufacturers like Samsung, but the company says the earliest their product will be out is 2009.

In contrast, Malhotra says Oorja is already selling its fuel cells to customers and working with OEMs (though he won’t name names). As we noted, Sequoia’s cleantech strategy is to invest in companies that already have a product ready. Malhotra says 2008 is the year that Oorja will make the shift from initial customers to mass commercialization.

It won’t be that easy to get people to buy fuel cells. They have had a hard time becoming mainstream because they rely on a supply of hydrogen, which can be difficult to handle and hard to develop an infrastructure around. The technology has also been prohibitively expensive. Malhotra thinks that if these two problems are addressed, it could be the tipping point for fuel cells, and he says cryptically that “Oorja will provide the complete solution.”

Malhotra, who has spent more than a decade researching fuel cells, founded the company in April 2005. The company has now raised around $21 million, led by Sequoia and DAG Ventures.

  1. 5 kilowatts is not big enough for vehicle applications. And we don’t need another forklift power source; propane works just fine, as do batteries.

    The main advantage of methanol is its liquid state, which in theory would be advantageous to vehicles. But without a applicable fuel cell format, that path is sunk. One could burn methanol in IC engines, but the automakers are all staying away from that, due to the toxicity of methanol. They do not consider methanol a viable future fuel at this point in time.

    Share
  2. [...] We’ve been hearing about stealthy fuel cell startup Oorja Protonics, since word got out in mid-2006 that the company was one of Sequoia’s first cleantech investments. Well, after recently surveying Sequoia’s potential killer cleantech … Read More [...]

    Share
  3. [...] by Katie Fehrenbacher No Comments Posted March 17th, 2008 at 10:02 am in Startups When we interviewed Sanjiv Malhotra, CEO of fuel startup Oorja Protonics, last month, the company was still in stealth mode. Guess they [...]

    Share
  4. Green energy is definitely the best solution in most cases. Technology like solar energy, wind power, fuel cells, zaps electric vehicles, EV hybrids, etc have come so far recently. Green energy even costs way less than oil and gas in many cases.

    Share
  5. Nareshkumar Ugranarashimaiah Sunday, June 15, 2008

    planning to launch in India . very much interesting . India is facing very acute power shortage need oorja like things

    Share
  6. Methanol fuel cells obviously cannot produce enough power to propel a car, but might they be useful as a means of extending the range and reducing recharge time of a battery electric vehicle by trickle-charging the battery on a 24/7 basis? Just a thought….

    Share
  7. [...] in 2005, Oorja has raised at least $21 million from Sequoia and DAG Ventures. CEO Sanjiv Malhotra told us early last year that the startup is targeting the battery market for fork lifts, pallet trucks and other material [...]

    Share
  8. [...] Cell Oorja Fuels Up: Fuel cell startup Oorja Protonics (which we’ve covered here and here) has raised $500,000 according to a regulatory filing — [...]

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post