5 Comments

Summary:

Katie just passed me word that the latest Playstation 3 model is getting a chipset that’ll greatly reduce its power consumption, from 200 watts to 135. Some Diggers are calling this an eco-friendly move: “By reducing power consumption on the new play station, Sony is trying […]

wii-prius.jpgKatie just passed me word that the latest Playstation 3 model is getting a chipset that’ll greatly reduce its power consumption, from 200 watts to 135. Some Diggers are calling this an eco-friendly move: “By reducing power consumption on the new play station, Sony is trying to attract the Green crowd,” one proclaims. EcoGeek concurs: “PS3 Gets Green(er)“. While I cover games for GigaOM, this is an angle I haven’t given much thought to until now. With the PS3 so far behind in the next-gen console wars (currently owning just 17 percent of the total console market, according to VGChartz), can Sony boost its appeal with environmentally sensitive gamers?

Hard to believe, because even with that reduction, the PS3 is a power hog. It’s like installing a low-wattage light bulb in the glove compartment of a Hummer and calling it eco-friendly. Which game platform provides the real green alternative?
An EcoGeek reader links to a fascinating HardcoreNet article from February, investigating the power consumption of the three next-gen consoles alongside the PC, and the contrast is stark enough to make Al Gore drop his fried chicken:

According to their report, the Xbox 360 runs at a peak consumption of 186 watts, the PC at 209 watts…while the Nintendo Wii consumes a mere 18.4 watts at peak. And because it comes with wireless connection and a downloadable Opera web browser, it’s even a limited alternative to the power-sucking PC. What’s more, its wireless remote and crossover games makes it appealing to household members besides the 18-34 dude demographic which comprise the 360/PS3’s main audience, offering a low-power entertainment alternative to everyone.

Essentially, the Wii is the Prius of game consoles. But unlike the car industry, where the Prius is still niche, the Wii is the undisputed market leader, with one forecast suggesting it’ll be in one out of every three homes by 2011. So maybe environmentalists will take up the push for even greater Nintendo domination. Suggested slogan: “Plant a tree, buy a Wii.”

  1. This is anecdotally clear (?) to me. We have a PS2 and a Wii in my house and you can hear the difference when the two are on. The Wii is nearly silent while the PS2’s CD drive and fan both make tons of noise.

    Also, per a tip from the Calif Cleantech Open, turn the machines off when not playing. Apparently lots of people/kids turn off the TV, but not the game player.

    With luck the manufacturers will figure out how to do this automatically in the near future.

    Share
  2. The one caveat is that you want to be sure to turn off Connect24 on the Wii. Otherwise, the Wii will use 9.6 watts when it is on standby. If you play 1 hour a day and have it on standby in Connect24 for 23 hours then you will use 171+9.623=238wh. The PS3 would come in slightly less at 1851 + 1.923= 229wh.

    Share
  3. Hmm, I guess asterisks get turned into bolds. Let me try that again:

    If you play 1 hour a day and have it on standby in Connect24 for 23 hours then you will use 17 x 1 + 9.6 x 23 = 238wh. The PS3 would come in slightly less at 185 x 1 + 1.9 x 23= 229wh.

    Share
  4. [...] shopping for eco-conscious gamers just got more complicated. Earlier this month, we lauded the energy efficiency of the Nintendo Wii, especially when compared to their power-hogging competitors, Microsoft’s Xbox 360 and [...]

    Share
  5. [...] shopping for eco-conscious gamers just got more complicated. Earlier this month, we lauded the energy efficiency of the Nintendo Wii, especially when compared to their power-hogging competitors, Microsoft’s Xbox 360 and [...]

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post