22 Comments

Summary:

[qi:011] Update: Hey Michael when you say, “Om Malik says Facebook traffic is tanking” it is not quite true. As I said in my original Facebook-traffic post from late last night, I don’t quite buy it. My exact words, “It just doesn’t make any sense! Unless […]

[qi:011] Update: Hey Michael when you say, “Om Malik says Facebook traffic is tanking” it is not quite true. As I said in my original Facebook-traffic post from late last night, I don’t quite buy it. My exact words, “It just doesn’t make any sense! Unless of course, the unthinkable is happening. I hope to chat with FB tomorrow and get more on this.”

Well, I haven’t been able to get Facebook to respond, but I did talk to others and have gotten to the bottom of this “dip/tanking” issue. Paul Sutter, co-founder & president of Quantcast explains that the dip we are seeing is because of the panel model adopted by comScore.

ComScore has a panel that has a bias toward Internet users who log on from home. The same is true of all measurement panels – Nielsen, Hitwise or Quantcast. As kids go back to school, they vanish from the panel, even though they are still using Facebook, from school dorms. “We have a hybrid model, a combination of panel and direct measurement,” he says. Direct measurement means a website places a Quantcast pixel on their website and that is used to measure. Sutter points out that their own panel also saw a similar dip, but in reality if direct measurement was in place, the traffic should go up.”

ComScore’s Andrew Lipsman disagrees with Quantcast explaination.

Quantcast’s claim that the comScore panel has a home bias is nonsense. comScore’s panel includes home, work, and university audiences and each sample is weighted and projected according to the size of the respective Internet population.

Of course, it would help, if Facebook explained what’s the story.

Facebook spokeswoman just got in touch from London and explains….

It’s important to note that we focus on active monthly users rather than registered users. Active monthly users in the U.S. grew from 17.7 million in August to 19.4 million in September. This active monthly user base has been growing at a rate of about 3 percent per week since January 2007 which means we have been doubling about every six months. Globally, we ended September with 44 million active monthly users as compared to nearly 9 million active monthly users for the same month in 2006. Our page views have also been increasing and went from 54 billion page views for August to 57 billion page views in September.

That settles it for me!

(My original update is below the fold with information and data from ComScore and Hitwise.)

Well well well….thank God for my disbelief. The 9.3 percent decline in unique visitors and 3.8 percent decline in page views for Facebook in September are part of a historical pattern. Hitwise and comScore have both confirmed this information. Andrew Lipsman of comScore left a message in response to our previous post:

Last year, there was a similar dip in visitation at Facebook, which suggests there are some seasonal factors at play. Another important factor that has not been mentioned is that September has 1 fewer day than August. Assuming all other things are equal, there would be approximately 3 percent less traffic in September just because it has fewer days. So a fair portion of the decline can be explained by that factor. Always be careful in looking at one month trends, because seasonality can always be an issue.

The Hitwise spokesperson had this to say, in addition to the historical chart they sent our way:

There is a small dip for Facebook in terms of U.S. visits it appears for the last few weeks, but looking back over time this could be more seasonal than anything. We’ll know more in the coming weeks.

hitwise facebook stock data

We are still waiting to hear back from Facebook. More when I have that information.

Update: Andy from Marketing Pilgrim got this information before I did. Good work Andy!

  1. Om, if you’d read my comment I left on your previous post, you’d have had this data hours ago. :-(

    Share
  2. Hey Andy

    I was on the road, and also I wanted to wait for the guys from Facebook to get back. Anyway good work. Sorry about not being able to link it.

    Share
  3. No problem, being on the road is a pain for all bloggers. Thanks for the link.

    Share
  4. Since all the measurement panels (Comscore, Netratings, Quantcast, Compete, Hitwise) share this same home-bias flaw, all of these panel measurements will show the same flaw.

    Direct measurement is really the only way to solve this problem.

    Share
  5. This has created such a stir, funny how the explanation doesn’t get as much play. Good find!

    Share
  6. [...] platform 2) Facebook traffic apparently took a dip last month — [Update: Or didn’t. See Om’s update, and a big looping conversation about Facebook on Techmeme] 3) Madonna latest in string of [...]

    Share
  7. disbeliever here!

    Share
  8. You should also have Comscore comment on what would be a simply monstrous flaw in their methodology. If this is correct Comscore is misreporting traffic all over the place. The home bias would affect many sites in different ways.

    Share
  9. Measurement “experts” huh? “LOL”

    Om Malik wrote a post last night about a Facebook traffic drop but was skeptical of the validity of the information. Today Om explained the drop in an update post where Paul Sutter, co-founder president of Quantcast told him the

    Share
  10. The huge increase of Facebook´s traffic in Europe will compensate this small loss in US i believe.

    Share
  11. Thanks for researching this weird dip.
    In Israel, Facebook has become extremely popular in the past month or two. Everyone’s talking about it, and some bloggers that objected FB publicly have also joined in…

    Share
  12. [...] 2004 Loving Links Friday October 12th 2007, 10:22 am Filed under: Links 1. Giga OM – Facebook Dip Seasonal, Here is [...]

    Share
  13. Andrew Lipsman, comScore Friday, October 12, 2007

    Quantcast’s claim that the comScore panel has a home bias is nonsense. comScore’s panel includes home, work, and university audiences and each sample is weighted and projected according to the size of the respective Internet population.

    Share
  14. Also keep in mind that as students return to school, Greek rush week events occur. At UCSD at least, all of the girls in the Greek system disable their Facebook accounts and set MySpace privacy to maximum during the week due to Panhellenic regulations. I’m pretty sure this has quite an effect.

    Also, look for the drop when people disable Facebook accounts for Lent. (This is noticed internally, though the outward effect on stats may be minimal.)

    Share
  15. Question? Do these statistics companies still only using ie to collect their data? How would many college kids going from their parents pc to their new shiny mac that runs safari/firefox effect these numbers?

    Share
  16. I knew facebook was still owning up!! Haha, I’m glad to see they are not suffering losses. Thanks for clearing it up!
    http://scott47.wordpress.com/

    Share
  17. Gotta love the guy who offers the greek week explanation. Dude there are not enough greeks in Greece to account for that drop.

    As I mentioned on your previous post. Why are you comparing a chart of ‘total uniques’ with a chart of ‘US market share’???

    These graphs are two completely different animals. Social sites don’t take as much of a summer hit as the net in general so the broad based net pick up at the end of summer last year showed a drop in FB market share. Yet they still increased total uniques last year. That’s not the case this year.

    Nice try with byzantine quantcast explanation, why don’t you stop rationalizing and just accept multiple independent streams of data from other sources that agree with dip??

    So… you were wrong.

    Share
  18. [...] Facebook’s seasonal traffic changes Facebook traffic, according to GigaOm, has seasonal lulls, and a Facebook official helps to confirm this is true. Others wonder if the numbers that GigaOm was [...]

    Share
  19. [...] minutes of site activity a day. Internet darling Facebook receives disproportionate coverage with 18 million active monthly users in August, but last May, was averaging just 186 minutes in activity a month. The top games from [...]

    Share
  20. Facebook will die now. There is already a growing backlash since the new ads release.

    Share
  21. [...] network. Om Malik cleared some of the confusion up, when he revealed that this was sort of a seasonal dip and that “the 9.3 percent decline in unique visitors and 3.8 percent decline in page [...]

    Share
  22. [...] GigaOm reported that Facebook’s traffic has tanked a little, is it true or is it just speculation? Could all the Apps be annoying users away from Facebook? I don’t think we’ll ever really know since Facebook is a closed network, but for sure there are some stats that are positive: user numbers are up and user numbers outside of the US are growing tremendously quick. Australia’s the fastest growing region in Asia-Pac and HongKong network has nearly twice the numbers of the Singapore network. Nevertheless the Singapore network is definitely thriving. [...]

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post