11 Comments

Summary:

Here we go again. In the inexhaustible game of leapfrog between Silicon Valley chipmakers Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) and Intel Corp (INTC), it’s AMD’s turn to jump. Today, after more than six months of delays, the Sunnyvale, Calif. underdog of the multiprocessor arch-rivalry finally announced the […]

Here we go again. In the inexhaustible game of leapfrog between Silicon Valley chipmakers Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) and Intel Corp (INTC), it’s AMD’s turn to jump. Today, after more than six months of delays, the Sunnyvale, Calif. underdog of the multiprocessor arch-rivalry finally announced the launch of its quad-core processor “Barcelona” chip.

The release of the Quad Core Opteron chip series certainly has market share implications for AMD, but we’ll let Om fill you in on what it means for the business. We’re more interested in just how power-efficient AMD managed to make its new chip.

An AMD spokesperson claims that the 75-Watt 2 GHz Barcelona processor, when compared to Intel’s 2.3 GHz Xeon processor, is on average 26 percent faster across a variety of server workloads, while managing to draw less power and require less cooling than Intel. In one given server workload test, AMD’s new processor proved to be “65 to 70 percent faster” while using “five less watts, on average,” of energy compared to Intel’s Xeon processor.

That’s using AMD’s new energy consumption metrics, called ACP, or average CPU power, that includes more than just the processor cores when determining energy usage of the microprocessor. Since Intel doesn’t have an integrated memory controller, it “allows the chip maker to post lower energy consumption data for its chip,” but it also “draws additional energy to the chipset and impacts performance,” says Tom Sanders of VNU Net.

Meanwhile, AMD’s “numbers are a little fuzzy,” says Roger Kay, president of research firm Endpoint Technologies. Right now the only stats on Barcelona’s power-per-watt efficiency are from AMD, and we can’t trust those stats entirely without any third-party research. Mercury Research President Dean McCarron agrees. “The way these things get measured there’s a lot of room to alter the results,” he said.

Even so, AMD is touting the power efficiency of its new chip. How does AMD reduce the energy usage of its chip? Having the quad-core processor on a single die, the company explains, allows the cores to “efficiently communicate and perform work without having to leave the processor package.”

The chip’s technology also reduces energy consumption by allowing processors and cores to “operate at various voltages and and frequencies, depending on usage.” When a chip has four cores, if all of them are draining energy all the time, that’s a major energy waste. But if a chip can turn off unused parts of the processor, it will be more energy efficient.

Kay tells us that by using AMD’s “direct connect” memory architecture, the company’s latest chip is able to do its processing work without “much energy overhead.” But Kay said the difference is a slight one.

“On a raw performance measure they might have a slight edge at the introduction of Barcelona, but the performance-per-watt edge might be more durable. It might last a little longer because architectural changes are difficult to make. Intel is not going to incorporate [their version of] direct connect memory until 2008. But most advantages in this industry are really temporary.” – Roger Kay, Endpoint Technologies.

When it comes to IT purchasing decisions, the power drainage of a chip is almost, if not equally, as important as processing speed. The energy consumption of servers and data centers has doubled in the past five years and is expected to nearly double again over the next five years, to more than 100 billion kWh, according to the EPA, at a cost of about $7.4 billion a year.

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. How Green is AMD’s Barcelona? « GigaOM Monday, September 10, 2007

    [...] to industry experts it seems Barcelona isn’t going to have that much of an eco-impact. Continue Reading. Share This | Sphere | Topic: Shorts [...]

  2. The Daily Sprout « Earth2Tech Monday, September 10, 2007

    [...] First Third-Party Tests: AMD released its long-awaited quad core microprocessor today. The first outside reviews of the chip are popping up online – Tech Report; Real World [...]

  3. AMD vs. Intel – Barcelona’s Slight Energy Advantage « Edutainment & Convergence Today Monday, September 10, 2007

    [...] read more | digg story [...]

  4. Gee, I wonder is AMD is Green enough for Apple and their iMac?

  5. The AMD Barcelona | Andrew Barnett Wednesday, September 12, 2007

    [...] AMD vs. Intel: Barcelona’s Slight Energy Advantage [...]

  6. Intel Developing Green Tracking Gadget « Earth2Tech Tuesday, September 18, 2007

    [...] Fehrenbacher No Comments Posted September 18th, 2007 at 8:50 am in Energy AMD and Intel might haggle over the power efficiencies of their chips, but we didn’t expect to hear about Intel developing anything close to a green consumer [...]

  7. Intel’s Nehalem Focused on Power Efficiency « Earth2Tech Thursday, September 20, 2007

    [...] Leave it to Intel (INTC) to try to rain on AMD’s (AMD) parade. Less than two weeks after AMD sang out praises of its new chip’s power efficiency with the launch of its “Barcelona”…, Intel is showing off its latest innovation in chip architecture — “Nehalem” — [...]

  8. The Secret to Intel’s Power-Efficient Chips: Hafnium « Earth2Tech Friday, November 9, 2007

    [...] 1:00 pm in Energy Witness the jockeying between rival chipmakers Intel (INTC) and AMD (AMD) over whose chips are more energy-efficient, and it’s clear that power-saving chips are the future of the semiconductor industry. Intel [...]

  9. Earth2Tech » Blog Archive » The Secret to Intel’s Power-Efficient Chips: Hafnium Friday, November 9, 2007

    [...] the jockeying between rival chipmakers Intel (INTC) and AMD (AMD) over whose chips are more energy-efficient, and it’s clear that power-saving chips are the future of the semiconductor industry. Intel [...]

  10. toyota centr ekspluataciya toyota prodazha toyota oficialnyy diler toyota kuzov toyota avtosalon toyota oficialnyy diler toyota toyota foto toyota tehnicheskie

Comments have been disabled for this post