8 Comments

Summary:

Note from Liz: Chris Albrecht is NewTeeVee’s newest staff writer. I’ll post a formal introduction to him soon, but he just couldn’t wait for the long weekend to end to get started. Babelgum (the “other” peer-to- peer Internet TV startup), will host an online film festival […]

Note from Liz: Chris Albrecht is NewTeeVee’s newest staff writer. I’ll post a formal introduction to him soon, but he just couldn’t wait for the long weekend to end to get started.

Babelgum (the “other” peer-to-
peer Internet TV startup), will host an online film festival to “reward the very best in international independent short filmmaking.” They even got Spike Lee to be an “honorary” judge (read: he’ll only watch a handful of of flicks).

Aspriring filmmakers can upload their films for consideration to the fest beginning September 15. Accepted submissions will be shown on Babelgum’s Online Film Festival Channel where the public will rate their favorites. The top ten rated films in each category go on to the jury.

It’s great that Babelgum is creating a program to recognize the short film format, but a closer look at the rules for entry indicate that Babelgum
a.) doesn’t get short films, or (more surprisingly) short-form content online; and
b.) is offering a raw deal forfilmmakers. See why after the jump.

Shorties
First thing that immediately jumps out from the announcement is that Babelgum will accept films under 45 minutes.

Forty. Five. Minutes.

Crimeny. That’s not a short, that’s a long. That’s a too-long. That’s a too long for online audiences who crave their packed-tight, bite-sized bits of entertainment.

They would have been much better off limiting the run times to 20 minutes and under. Sure, that wouldn’t create as many hours of programming to pad their content library — but it would be a better
experience for the user (most short films over 20 minutes feel like an eternity), and there is still a vast pool of films in that timeframe to choose from.

Think Twice
More importantly, there are two reasons why a short filmmaker should take a serious look at this before entering:

  1. Exclusivity: The announcement states: “Babelgum will hold
    exclusive online rights to all accepted films from March 2008 to
    March 2009.” Want to post your film elsewhere online next year? Too
    bad, your work will only be seen by people with Babelgum.
    Babelgum revised their stance, check out the update.
  2. Real-world consequences: Many festivals are still
    reluctant to include films that can be viewed online. They don’t like
    charging people for something they can see for free online. It’s
    something to consider if a filmmaker wants to run the festival circuit.

But if Babelgum really wants to “reward” short filmmakers — it’s
missing the most important part of a festival: the after party (with
a hosted bar, of course).

You're subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. [...] by Om Malik Sunday, September 2, 2007 at 10:55 AM PT | No comments Babelgum (the “other” peer-to-peer Internet TV startup), will host an online film festival to [...]

    Share
  2. Great first post Chris!

    You are right on the button with this one.

    I feel the same way about online video contests that promise award money only to get other people to work for free.

    Share
  3. Hi Liz/Chris.

    Thanks for the post. We just posted some clarifications on rights (the press release was not very clear about it, sorry, our bad) and other things.

    http://www.babelgum.com/blog/?p=55

    Some quick notes.

    There will be a monetary prize of 20.000 USD for each winner, as announced at the Venice press conference.
    Duration is up to 45 minutes, except for the short section where is 20 minutes, it was already in yesterday’s post and press release.
    Concerning your point “Real-world consequence”, that is mere speculation. We, and many festivals that shared their content with us, don’t really see it that way.

    And, most important of all (I agree), as announced at the press conference, there will be an award ceremony, most probably in Cannes, during the 2008 Film Festival.

    Share
  4. [...] for aspriring filmmakers interested in the upcoming Babelgum Online Film Festival we wrote about yesterday. Babelgum clarified its stance on exclusivity (hooray!) and broadened eligibility for its fest. [...]

    Share
  5. [...] NewTeeVee’s newest staff writer, Chris Albrecht. You’ll already be familiar with the top-notch work he submitted over the long weekend and [...]

    Share
  6. The Producers Guild of America’s upcoming seminar – “Preparing for the Infinite Channel Universe” on November 10t in Studio City, CA needs experts for panels.

    Share
  7. [...] new features and opened up voting for its online film festival this week (a fest we’ve been skeptical of in the [...]

    Share
  8. [...] Babelgum to Become (Doomed) Studio Babelgum said today it’s creating a 10 million euro ($15.4 million) fund to invest in new (and exclusive) original content. “We are going down the road of transforming into a digital media studio,” Babelgum CEO Valerio Zingarelli told Variety. Though it’s clearly not a bad idea to create your own content, this is the second time Babelgum has been on the right train, but the wrong track. [...]

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post