9 Comments

Summary:

[qi:074] It is not often someone decides to take on the Federal Communications Commission head-on, especially if you happen to be a start-up that is looking to get about 20 MHz of spectrum for free. But Menlo Park, Calif.-based M2Z Networks is willing to risk it […]

[qi:074] It is not often someone decides to take on the Federal Communications Commission head-on, especially if you happen to be a start-up that is looking to get about 20 MHz of spectrum for free. But Menlo Park, Calif.-based M2Z Networks is willing to risk it all.

The company is ready to take FCC to the court, asking courts to intervene and get the FCC to become compliant with Section 7 of the Telecommunications Act and making a public interest determination on M2Z’s license application that has been pending for over 15 months. The FCC was statutorily required to make a public interest determination on M2Z’s license application by May 5, 2007. To date, this has not occurred.

It was in May 2006, when M2Z a company started by John Muleta, the head of the FCC’s Wireless Telecommunications Bureau, filed an application with the FCC, asking the commission to give it the fallow spectrum in the 2155-2175 MHz band for free. In exchange, M2Z has promised to build a nationwide broadband wireless network and operate it as a wholesale network, and cover 95% of the US population. In exchange, the company would give 5% of its gross revenues to the US Treasury. M2Z is backed by Kleiner, Perkins, Caufield and Byers, Charles River Ventures and Redpoint Ventures.

Over the last 15 months, M2Z says it repeatedly called on the Commission before the statutory deadline of May 5, 2007. FCC’s decision making process can be quite glacial. Milo Medin, architect of @Home Networks, one of the first cable-based broadband networks pointed out that by not moving on the application, FCC is showing that it doesn’t care much for increased competition in the broadband market. (Press Release.)

I have been skeptical of this broadband utopia for various reasons including the blue-sky nature of the network. It is not a trivial task, fraught with risks. In addition, there is no clarity on technology used for this network. More importantly, there is this little bit in their application, Mandatory Filtering of Indecent and Obscene Material, which seems to be a bit anti-Internet to me. My reservations aside, M2Z shouldn’t be denied its due process, and that’s precisely what FCC Chairman Martin seems to be doing.

According to Dow Jones News Wires, sometime last week, FCC Chairman Martin’s office had “circulated a proposed decision to the other four commissioners that would deny M2Z’s plan.” Muleta says if FCC Chairman can give a good enough reason to dismiss their application, so be it, but they are not doing that.

Muleta had some tough words for FCC Chairman Martin, and is not ready to give up without a fight.

Chairman Martin’s staff is using arguments that are nonsensical, not supported by the evidence in the record, and would not stand the light of day in a court. Martin’s staff proposed solution is “start a lengthy rulemaking” to determine what to do with this spectrum which is exactly what the incumbents have called for in opposing M2Z over the last 15 months since we went public(no new entrants and death by inaction).

Muleta says Martin hasn’t been able to do one job that he has been tasked to do by the US Congress: make a decision. By not taking a decision, “what they are saying is that they are afraid to make a decision that upsets AT&T and Verizon,” says Muleta. “I want them to tell me how free (broadband) is not in public interest.”

He argued that this slice of spectrum has been lying fallow for seven years and the FCC hasn’t auctioned it, now is time to put it to some use. The FCC for over a decade has been in favor of selling off the spectrum in auctions, and not give it away for free.

When asked why M2Z should get spectrum for free, Muleta said, “We are giving the US treasury 5% of revenue in perpetuity, so we are paying for the spectrum. What we are doing is fighting a process where company with $8 billion of cash flow is buying up spectrum and controlling it, and not using it.”

  1. M2Z Seeks Court Help with FCC Decision

    It’s been less than three weeks since the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) announced its rules for the upcoming 700 MHz auction, a subject of much debate as various players vie for the coveted spectrum. Now, as GigaOm reports, there’s another

    Share
  2. Jesse Kopelman Thursday, August 16, 2007

    I’d rather see the FCC go Japanese on this one and make the spectrum unlicensed with a tariff on devices. Make the tariff progressive based on output power and you’ve got compelling spectrum to support rural community wireless broadband. Too bad onbody asked me ;^)

    Share
  3. [...] FCC petition by M2Z is 15 months old, it seems like the FCC Chairman is ignoring it. According to GigaOm, M2Z is taking the FCC to court to get its due process, the process detailed in Section 7 of the [...]

    Share
  4. News happening now…24-Year Term for Californian in Terrorism Training Case

    Stories this blog was used in… 24-Year Term for Californian in Terrorism Training Case

    Share
  5. [...] want to pay for the spectrum. The FCC ignored their request, so M2Z turned around and sued. They have to be feeling a tad vindicated by Martin’s latest move for free [...]

    Share
  6. [...] plans to use the AWS-3 band for its wireless broadband network, but spectrum holders in the AWS-1 band–notably T-Mobile– claimed such devices would [...]

    Share
  7. [...] Spectrum: A Kleiner-backed company called M2Z Networks has asked the FCC for use of the spectrum in the 2155-2175 MHz band to create a wireless broadband service. M2Z offered the FCC 5 percent of [...]

    Share
  8. [...] and a carrier would sell access to the faster tier for all comers. The rule making was similar to a proposal created by the Kleiner-backed startup M2Z Networks, which had asked the FCC to give it the spectrum for [...]

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post