12 Comments

Summary:

Good news, investors! eBay’s stock is trading at a value. It’s priced at 25 times the $1.36 a share that is the mid-point of the company’s guidance for net earnings this year. A P-E ratio of 25 is, in general, pretty high. But for a company […]

Good news, investors! eBay’s stock is trading at a value. It’s priced at 25 times the $1.36 a share that is the mid-point of the company’s guidance for net earnings this year. A P-E ratio of 25 is, in general, pretty high. But for a company whose profit will grow 30% this year – significantly faster than revenue – that’s a value.

Now for the bad news: eBay’s been a value for most of this year, and nobody seems to care. Which raises an ugly question: What if the market continues to not care? Buying a value stock is useful only if other people decide after you do to buy it.

That’s not exactly happening with eBay. After posting a strong second-quarter earnings report, the stock has dropped more than 2% in after-hours trading as I write this.

Judging from some of the comments analysts made on the conference call, the mood-killing statistics seemed to be in the decline in the number of products listed for sale on eBay’s auction and e-commerce sites. Globally, they were down 6% this quarter. What’s more, gross merchandise volume (the total value of all goods sold through eBay’s core site) was up 12%, against 18% growth a year earlier.

When I spoke with eBay CFO Bob Swan, he pointed out that investors were reacting to concerns that the company told them about months ago. “We said that we’d be more focused on improving the buyer experience, and not as much on the number of listings,” Swan said. There were too many listings that were turning away buyers, so eBay started weeding them out.

As demand among buyers rises, listings should recover in the longer term. Meanwhile, there are signs that eliminating the “bad listings” is working – average prices of goods sold is up, as are conversion rates. And overall marketplace revenue is up 26%, above the 22% growth rate of a year ago.

Regarding Skype, Swan said that the unit has shown an operating profit for the second straight quarter. He declined to say what it was, but said it was approaching the 20% operating margin goal that eBay had set. Skype, which makes up less than 5% of eBay’s revenue, has brought in $364 million in the last six quarters, equal to 14% of the $2.6 billion eBay paid for it.

Om pointed out earlier an apparent paradox in the Skype data – revenue is rising even though minutes used were flattening out. Swan said that a subscription program that Skype had rolled out in North America was bringing in revenue to offset the lackluster growth in minutes used.

What’s holding back eBay’s stock? My guess is that eBay is a continual value because it’s a continual work in progress. To stay competitive in a market where growth rates aren’t quite what they used to be, eBay has to find profit growth by running an ever more efficient business or expanding into new areas of growth, or both. It’s chosen to do both.

But doing both has left the company looking like it’s always in the process of improving itself. By the time it’s reaping the fruits of earlier improvements, it’s already kicking up dust with a new round of improvements. So by focusing on gross merchandise volume, investors may be overlooking the growth in eBay units like Shopping.com, StubHub and Kijiji abroad that add to revenue without affecting GMV.

Beyond buying back more shares – eBay’s repurchased 75 million in the past 10 months – there’s little the company can do to entice investors back. Says Swan: “We’ll continue to focus on the matters at hand and let the rest take care of itself.” The only question being if and when the rest will take care of itself.

  1. Kevin, do you own any eBay stock? Did your research make you want to pick some up?

    Share
  2. [...] UPDATE: Apparently the guys over at GigaOm agree with me. Kevin Kelleher calls eBay and unwanted bargain in this article. [...]

    Share
  3. Kevin Kelleher Wednesday, July 18, 2007

    matt, I don’t own any individual stocks. I invest through mutual funds and ETF’s, for reasons that are too tedious to go into here. I hope my research (which some would call journalism) speaks for itself.

    Share
  4. It’s all about long term investing. As Warren Buffett would say, a stock will always trend toward its intrinsic value over time – it just may take longer than you think. Markets tend to be efficient in most cases.

    But then again, if you were Warren Buffett, you wouldn’t be buying tech stocks in the first place ;)

    Cheers,
    Aidan
    http://www.MappingTheWeb.com

    Share
  5. Maybe the risk factor is the offset to the growth rate, as you implied.

    Is this similar to Google’s stock price? Google continues to grow rapidly, yet stock price has remained flat.

    Share
  6. I own some shares of eBay because it’s such a great value play. My calculations put the “sticker price” at about $84… that’s a huge margin of safety compared to the current $33.30ish price.

    So really great article that mimics a lot of my current thinking right now. A lot of times with value plays like this us early investors wonder when the rest of the world will catch up. We need a couple of things: (1) a major catalyst to grab folks attention and/or (2) money to invest.

    RE (1), this past earnings call wasn’t enough. Maybe an earnings call where they tromp the expectations will work. Maybe a Jim Cramer endorsement. It’s really hard to say. I really liked the news that Google Checkout wasn’t gaining as much share as people expected and how eBay was standing up to Google. (In a world where everyone sells off stock when Google puts you in their crosshairs, it’s nice to see that at least someone can compete.) But that didn’t have legs.

    RE (2), folks are really happy with their GOOG, RIMM, BIDU, etc, etc investments right now. When they start taking profits from those, they’ll need to put the money somewhere else in the tech sector. eBay will be a good choice.

    We can just speculate about 1 & 2 up there, but the real reason one would invest in a value play like eBay here is that the downside is very limited. So I’m happy to tread water for a while until things get into gear. I’m thinking we’ll get closer to that $84 level over the next year or two. And even now, eBay is technically still in their uptrend (above 10-day moving average, 30-day, etc).

    A look at AMZN’s one year chart is encouraging. Value, value, value, value, still $40, BOOM doubled in price.

    On the other hand, a look at MSFT’s 7-year chart is discouraging. $25-$30 forever. But MSFT wasn’t really as much of a value play as eBay is here. Cheers!

    Share
  7. [...] Kelleher at GigaOM.com asks “What is holding back eBay’s [...]

    Share
  8. I’m just not sure about eBay. Maybe if there site wasn’t so ugly and was given a complete facelift I might feel different and buy some shares.

    Share
  9. well, maybe because investors are worried that the management team will take other moronic steps such as

    a) not acquiring google when they had the chance, apparently under 1B

    b) try to compensate for that and blow away 2.4Bn on a deal to buy a useless business like skype.

    that type of lack of judgement must scare even the boldest investor

    dude!

    Share
  10. ebay always takes a long time to load. if they improve that i would use it more as a resource. also i’d like to see them acquire amazon so we can have integration. i can go to amazon and automatically see if the item is offered on ebay. i suppose a greasemonkey user script can accomplish this, but…

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post