8 Comments

Summary:

Another week, another national government demanding that a clip on YouTube be censored. First it was the Brazilian courts, which ended up reversing its decision. This time it’s India’s Information and Broadcasting Ministry, which is up in arms over standup comedian Gautham Prasad’s sketch of Gandhi […]

Another week, another national government demanding that a clip on YouTube be censored. First it was the Brazilian courts, which ended up reversing its decision. This time it’s India’s Information and Broadcasting Ministry, which is up in arms over standup comedian Gautham Prasad’s sketch of Gandhi doing a strip tease.

Blog Pass the Roti deconstructed the media accounts, which seem to have inaccurately asserted that the clips showed Gandhi advocating violence. I think they might have gotten Prasad’s bit mixed up with the classic fake “Gandhi II” trailer from Weird Al Yankovic’s movie UHF. Prasad posted an explanation of his sketch on his personal site.

According to press reports, Google is reviewing the clip (which is currently flagged as “potentially offensive”). Meanwhile, India took “serious exception” to the airing of portions of the clip on two television networks, and also threatened to block YouTube if the clip wasn’t taken down. What I find hilarious is that in standup lingo the term used to describe things that you shouldn’t make fun of derives from Gandhi’s Hindu faith — “sacred cow.”

You’re subscribed! If you like, you can update your settings

  1. This video is in very bad taste and needs to be removed. I completely agree with Indian govt viewpoint …

  2. Evil thing. Must be removed. It shows how worst the YouTube is…

  3. “What I find hilarious is that in standup lingo the term used to describe things that you shouldn’t make fun of derives from Gandhi’s Hindu faith — “sacred cow7.” ”
    Yes this and lots of other English words are derived from the period of British rule in India. The meaning of the term ‘sacred cow’ shows that there are cultures where it is not completely ok to be completely ‘irreverent’, something that is probably not apparent in homogenised societies such as the US. That you find this hilarious suggests that you may want to read up to broaden your horizons a bit, if you seek a global audience for your musings.

  4. India » Blog Archive » Alcoa To Partner With India In Research Wednesday, January 17, 2007

    […] This time it s India s Information and Broadcasting Ministry, which is up in arms over standup comedian Gautham Prasad s sketch of Gandhi doing a strip tease. … Meanwhile, India took serious exception to the airing of portions of … – more – […]

  5. Well, I made the sacred cow comment alluding to the fact that, if any standup would understand the meaning behind the term, a comedian of south asian ancestry would be most likely to.

    I’m an advocate for freedom of expression, often even in extreme cases. Gandhi is a towering figure in human history, and I deeply respect and revere his legacy myself, especially in light of his influence of Dr. Martin Luther King who’s birthday I just celebrated.

    There is no requirement that anyone watch the video, or even visit YouTube. It’s a tame sketch in questionable taste — raising an uproar over it gives it more credit than it’s due.

    The artist in question gave his explanation for his decision, and while it may not be satisfying to many, it’s his decision to make, and I’ll stand by him on that. Maybe that’s an uncrossable cultural divide, but it’s one that has to be addressed in the new global market for ideas.

  6. Small Pandas » Archive » Reality Show can ruin many brands Wednesday, January 17, 2007

    […] Now coming back to impact of such reality show on brand : Carphone Warehouse is now under severe strain and reviewing sponsorship deal because it may be treated by Asian British community as not ethical and doesn’t care about Asian communities!! It is strange but that is how reality show play with emotions and if Channel 4 airs them to gain popularity without considering the impact, I think sponsorers may loose brand value by pissing of certain community, culture and intellectual mindset people. Also taking the same reality shows further, there are many cultural or privacy rows with YouTube recently. Unless such issues are taken into complete confidence, many global brands will find trapped inside conflicting communities/cultures. So only community moderation is not an answer to build safe, democratic and social networks or applications. Till then, sponsorers keep your brands safe and communicate your purpose to stakeholders. Share and Enjoy:These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages. […]

  7. I believe there nothing wrong to this caricature and M.K. Gandhi dancing. Mnay don;t know, gandhi was not happy with Kasturba and he wanted to marry Tagor’s daughter. I think he that, Gandhi has destrioed the country india. He is almost naked with a lion cloth and wanted to keep india naked and poor.he is the man or demon may be, suggested to Neheru to absorb his son-in law a Islamic fellow Khan and arranged wedding with Indiara Gandhi, it was mixed religion, Gandhi adopted Khan as his son and Neheru was pleased and cultivated M.K. Gandhi as Bapuji and father of India, it was a gift against gift to M.K. Gandhi and cunnigly Neheru became first PM of India. Till now the poors in india are facing maximum hardship and political leaders are exploiting the poor dalits in the name gandhibaba.I think the days are not far, gandhi will be rejected in india and the statue will faul down like saddam in iraq.Therefore I don’t think the vediclip is wrong and rapidely the truth is coming out by braking the lid of sealed can.
    Thanks
    David

  8. YouTube Cripples Itself to Protect Korean Users Monday, April 13, 2009

    [...] has had to deal with a barrage of government demands in the last few years, facing shutdowns in India, Turkey, and Brazil, and once Pakistan’s attempt to block the site lead to a global outage. [...]

Comments have been disabled for this post