42 Comments

Summary:

Okay, so you made it pretty clear that you’re not interested in Windows Home Server. I hear you. Forgive me. So what about the new Apple iPhone? In case you have been napping all day, Apple Inc. has finally revealed their first break-the-mold mobile device since […]

Apple iPhone credit macuser.comOkay, so you made it pretty clear that you’re not interested in Windows Home Server. I hear you. Forgive me. So what about the new Apple iPhone? In case you have been napping all day, Apple Inc. has finally revealed their first break-the-mold mobile device since the iPod. Phone, internet and an iPod all wrapped up in a to-die-for interface. I’m writing this based only on what Apple has on their site now (not much) and from reading the live stream out of Mac Rumors as it was happening.

Is this party day for the web worker?

Yes and no.

First the yes…

  • That interface. Apple has mastered the phrase “ease of use” to such an extent that it will take years for anyone else to come close, if ever.
  • Huge screen (by phone standards) and incredible resolution (320×480 at 160ppi!)
  • It runs OS X. Everything that’s good about OS X will be good about this phone.
  • Push IMAP. Blackberry? What Blackberry? I could easily see forwarding all my mail to the free push IMAP Yahoo account iPhone owners will get.
  • Google Maps so beautiful you could practically smell the Paris air in that satelite fly-over of the Eiffel Tower shown during the keynote.
  • Slick dialer. Review voicemail out of sequence. A presentation screen in the keynote said that the phone was the killer app and that appears to be true.
  • That whole multi-touch thing. I want to see it in action. Apparently it knows to dismiss accidental touches and other amazing feats.
  • Bluetooth and Wifi (and it automatically switches back and forth between Wifi and GPRS/EDGE).
  • Great battery life of 5 hours talk and 16 hours audio.

So what’s wrong? Not so much “wrong” as questions that are left unanswered as the “Apple Keynote Reality Distortion Field” wears off a bit…

  • $499 for the 4GB model, $599 for 8GB model. Even though it does what no other phone has ever attempted, that’s still steep. And with only 8GB flash memory it isn’t going to replace the iPod anytime soon.
  • Exclusively Cingular. Many have a love/hate relationship with Cingular, with good reason. What about folks who still have time left on their existing Cingular contracts? Will they be able to buy the phone at the contract rate and simply extend the contract, or will they have to wait until contract expiration as is current policy?
  • No mention of data plans. Currently Cingular offers 21 different data plans. 21! Where will the iPhone’s data plan fit in? Somewhere in the $40 range for unlimited data is my guess. I’m also guessing that this phone will get its own plan, to avoid confusion between the existing Data Connect and Smartphone plans. Even Cingular employees are confused about which of their 21 plans is right for which device, and which plans you can buy even though they weren’t meant for your phone but you can get away with it. I hope Apple’s exclusive deal with Cingular included some price protection on the data plan, otherwise Cingular can price it wherever they choose knowing that there is nowhere else for customers to go.
  • Why stop at EDGE? Why not the new high speed 3G network? The speed of the keynote demonstration over wifi was marvelous. What happens when it gets to real world speed over the much slower EDGE connections?
  • I know Apple’s stock went up today…I’m sure the folks who make the iKlear Apple Polish are also celebrating. Anyone who owns an iPod can attest to the fact that the clear plastic around the device scratches and mucks up easily. I know the 3rd party market will respond with at least 30 different products to contain and protect the iPhone well before it actually ships.
  • Of course this phone will sync seamlessly with iCal and Safari. What about PC users? What about folks using different calendar and contact applications? Different browsers (for bookmark syncing)?
  • Will other 3rd party applications be available for the device at launch…such as games, eBook readers, shopping lists, databases? We use our phones for more than just email, phone calls and media.

What do you think about the new iPhone? Is it the next iPod or the next eMate? If you don’t know what the eMate was, my point exactly. We have until June when this ships to figure it all out.

  1. I think that while I am on the search for probably just a phone like that, I can and have to wait. Basically it is not available in Europe and until it will I will buy a different phone.

    Yes, one can drool about it, but being on a PC and wanting a gps in it will make me go for a different phone. Which is why I was hoping it came out earlier – because then those prices would go down sooner for other devices.

    Although not being a mac fan, I admit they did something very nice and intergrated- and it will be probably great in a year or two. Besides – very clever to announce it now and give everybody a chance to make up their mind and get those non cingular plans cancelled. ;)

    Share
  2. In my opinion, the iPhone will be a hit with two select categories of consumers: 1. Mac users that are fed up with Windows Mobile devices and other mobile devices in general as well as PDAs in terms of syncing problematics and other issues. Just selling the iPhone to the Mac community (expecially here in Europe) will give a positive result to Apple; 2. People that don’t want carry around both an iPod and a mobile phone or those who don’t need the “big” iPod and want something integrated. The price isn’t that steep when we see how much Nokia for example charges for its “3G” devices. It’s not about the technology, it’s about giving people what they want and Apple will hopefully deliver yet again… Now I only have to wait 9 months… :)

    Share
  3. iPhone… Just… Wow!

    The iPhone is going to utterly change the smartphone landscape. Everyone else is now completely in catchup mode. Nothing more to say.
    Except that I have to wait until 2008 to get one! Dammit!
    Pages and pages of in depth commentary at:

    AppleInsider…

    Share
  4. I had my eye set on the release of the Nokia N95, until now. I just re-upped for a two year extension with T-Mobile. Guess I’ll have to decide in 5-6 months if a contract buyout is worth it.

    Also, first generation hardware from Apple can have it’s issues. Maybe since this has been in development for so long already, they’ve worked the kinks out? We can hope.

    Share
  5. I wasn’t a fanboy, until today. iPhone puts my Christmas-present-to-self, a Nano, to shame.

    Oh well, guess I’ll just have to upgrade in June. :-)

    BTW, I’ve posted specs and key pics from today’s keynote on my blog at:
    http://billday.com/2007/01/09

    and created an iPhone discussion forum where I hope the community will drill into developing for iPhone in coming months:
    http://billday.com/discuss/viewforum.php?f=5

    Share
  6. I’ll bet there will be a lot of unique things revealed by Apple/Cingular (plans, etc). It’s been said/reported that Cingular had to make network infrastructure changes to accomodate the voicemail feature. That sounds a lot more difficult than just rearranging a plan structure.
    ———-
    On a side note. This is the first phone I’ve seen that will allow my 83 year old father to actually retrieve his voicemail. There’s just no way he groks the current Verizon multi-step system…call VM, enter password, press different keys depending on what you want/need to do, etc.

    Share
  7. The big question, of course, is whether it’ll blend up in one of those high powered blenders? We know the iPod blends, we know golf balls blend, and as for the Constitution of the United States….

    http://markdaycomedy.wordpress.com/2007/01/10/will-it-blend-ipods-iphones-the-constitution/

    Share
  8. I just finished watching the keynote, and was hanging out until the end for a “One more thing: We’re going to destroy the phone companies with easy integrated VOIP!”

    Well, it didn’t come, so I’m left with the question: Where’s the seamless integrated VOIP app!
    Let’s hope the SDKs are on their way to developers soon. I use and tolerate SJPhone on my Windows Mobile Device, so even just a straight port of SJPhone will do for now, but what I’d really like is to have VOIP integrated: When Wifi’s available, send the call via the SIP provider you’ve set up. Use all the cool contact features and Ipod pausing/awesome interface as is… No mention of the Australian release date (Asia in 2008, so does that include us?), so by then maybe someone will have taken care of this.

    Share
  9. They Finally Did It.. the iPhone

    Share
  10. i really want one, but the price IS very steep, and i’m a t-mobile user. :(

    Share

Comments have been disabled for this post