Nicholas Carr, The Bad Boy

Om Malik, Monday, October 24, 2005 at 8:51 AM PT Comments (2)

The blogosphere just woke up from collective deep sleep and discovered Nicholas Carr’s post on amateurs. I wrote about it last week, 2 weeks after Carr wrote it. So what triggered the buzz today? A story in the big media aka San Jose Mercury News by Mike Langberg. Enough said!

Rating: 50% Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
Print

2 comments so far

October 24th, 2005
9:30 AM PT
Andrew Lin said:

I approached his post with caution but came out a hessitant believer. I’m writing more about it here.

October 24th, 2005
3:16 PM PT
EsmeV said:

Members of the “professional” press (AKA Mainsteam Press) complain, like Carr, about the “amateur” press (AKA bloggers). Problem is many bloggers do a much better job than the “professional” press not necessarily for reasons of quality, but time and focus. Most journalists who work at mainstream publications are not (and cannot) be experts in every single field they cover. Bloggers can fill in that gap and help journalists write better stories. My blog, Muniwireless.com, has done just that and I have been very happy working with journalists in mainstream publications (e.g. the Wall Street Journal).

I don’t know if I am an “amateur” (in the derogatory sense) in the eyes of Carr and others like Mike Langberg of the SJ Mercury News. Actually I don’t care if that’s what they think of me and my site. I just keep doing what I do.

Leave a Comment

Get the comments RSS feed, instant notification of new comments

Most Comments

FriendFeed. More Like (Fake)FriendFeed
Om Malik, July 7, 30 comments
Bandwidth Barons Want More Money for Fewer Bytes
Allan Leinwand, July 3, 25 comments
With Summize, Twitter to Buy a Clue
Om Malik, July 7, 23 comments
Five Nines on the Net is a Pipe Dream
Stacey Higginbotham, July 6, 17 comments
The Real Reason Powerset Sold (Out)
Om Malik, July 2, 16 comments
Close
E-mail It