In A Broadband Minute

Om Malik | Monday, September 26, 2005 | 11:07 PM PT | 4 comments

Some notable broadband links from around the web -

4 comments so far

Tom Raftery said:

Om, don’t know if you saw the story that Be are offering 24mb broadband in the UK for £24 per month…
See this Guardian story for more:
(link)

Om Malik said:

tom,

thanks for the link, i had this on sunday

Matt Sherman said:

Hi Om, appreciate your blog very much. Regarding the bit on the Heartland Institute — what’s the difference between a bias and a point of view? In fact, their analysis is spot on.

The state of wireless availability is a reflection of customer demand and economics, not a “failure”.

It is inevitable that muni WiFi will be more expensive (actual costs, not consumer price) and lower performing than the commercial alternatives.

Broadband penetration is growing at a brisk pace in *many* forms. Why mess with it?

Here’s more: (link)

Cheers,
- Matt

October 2nd, 2005
4:33 PM PT
Adina Levin said:

Broadband growth in the US has grown at a slower pace than elsewhere in the developed world. Demand is related to price, and US price is 10x the price in Japan and Korea. Service in the US is provided by an oligopoly which is keeping prices high and supply constrained.

Market fundamentalist critiques of muni broadband leave out a few critical points.

* the Heartland Institute criticizes government supported broadband, but doesn’t criticize government subsidies for their incumbent telecom funders. After all, government spending is bad only when it goes to somebody else.

* Competition helps keep prices down, and US telecom policy is to reward the oligopoly.

* Some kinds of public goods are well-suited to goverment support. Libraries, local roads, and elementary education aren’t run for profit. Society has decided that these things are required infrastructure, and there’s a decent argument that broadband service is basic infrastructure like roads.

Leave a Comment

Get the comments RSS feed, instant notification of new comments

Editorial Masthead

Carolyn Pritchard
Managing Editor
Celeste LeCompte
Special Projects Editor
Om Malik
Senior Writer
Stacey Higginbotham
Staff Writer
Wagner James Au
Contributing Editor
Liz Gannes
Staff Writer
Chris Albrecht
Staff Writer
Katie Fehrenbacher
Staff Writer
Josie Garthwaite
Staff Writer
Close
E-mail It