How broadband is broadband voice?

Om Malik, Saturday, March 12, 2005 at 8:47 AM PT Comments (2)

I admit, codecs are something I don’t pay much attention to. But Aswath does, and today he points out that one of the reason why SkypeOut doesn’t sound as good as Skype-pure, is because the gateway makers don’t support wideband codecs which Skype uses. What it means is that while Skype leverages the total broadband experience, SkypeOut means that voice coming from broadband networks has to well hide its muscles and act like a little ninny when hitting the traditional networks. (Incidentally SkypeOut has a million users, which I guess would make it the largest Voice over the net company!) Aswath says the current generation of ATAs also do pretty much the same thing.

While we are on the topic of codecs, one of the issues with ATA based deployments is that it is not feasible to add wideband codec to the ATA, since the standard telephones sample only at the baseband. I hope that the new breed of cordless phone based IP phones pay attention to this and build their handsets so that they can operate at the wideband frequencies.

Rating: 60% Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
Print

2 comments so far

March 12th, 2005
10:46 AM PT
NevOn said:

Why SkypeOut calls sound different

Now this is useful to know - a simple explanation as to why a phone call via SkypeOut doesn’t always have good audio quality. I’m thinking in particular of the interview with Michael Wiley of GM that Shel and I

March 15th, 2005
6:53 AM PT

Broadband Voice and the PSTN

Several blogs (Om Malik, Aswath Rao, Andy Abramson) write about how the voice quality of SkypeOut is not as good as the voice quality of Skype…

Leave a Comment

Get the comments RSS feed, instant notification of new comments

Most Comments

10 Reasons Enterprises Aren’t Ready to Trust the Cloud
Stacey Higginbotham, July 1, 44 comments
Inside Microsoft’s Internet Infrastructure & Its Plans For The Future
Om Malik, June 30, 25 comments
Bandwidth Barons Want More Money for Fewer Bytes
Allan Leinwand, July 3, 21 comments
State of U.S. Broadband: Demand Hits Speed Bumps
Om Malik, July 2, 16 comments
The Real Reason Powerset Sold (Out)
Om Malik, July 2, 15 comments

Highest Rated

Bandwidth Barons Want More Money for Fewer Bytes
Allan Leinwand, July 3, 70%
10 of the Biggest Platform Development Mistakes
Marty Abbott and Michael Fisher, June 30, 65%
Inside Microsoft’s Internet Infrastructure & Its Plans For The Future
Om Malik, June 30, 64%
No More AT&T Callvantage?
Om Malik, July 3, 69%
Meebo’s Jen: How to Find Hard-to-Find Talent
Carleen Hawn, July 5, 70%
Close
E-mail It